Ostrom_5-52


Чтобы посмотреть этот PDF файл с форматированием и разметкой, скачайте его и откройте на своем компьютере.
  :
 
  :
 
.. 
.
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
�*,  :;  +-�� 8  FC**/=*; *
*, =�: C=�� +: A, /
A* B*� A -/@*;, C    *A   6* 8 :*, +-&#x*, ;&#x-9.8;&#x-19;&#x.8+-;.8;&#x-40.; 80;&#x*, ;&#x-9.8;&#x-19;&#x.8+-;.8;&#x-40.; 80; 8 , +  
- * + *
�*, - D * *
 
* 8  *[email protected] *
-� ?
�8 * B�� : * �:.  /�� / * �*  +D &#x30.;-; .9;*
��=*   C=  *
�  C *?
� 8  BH  * C� / 8   �*/=�  6 *,  @, C  
�/ * �  :   *+ +-�� 8  **;&#x/=;&#x* 00; **;&#x/=;&#x* 00; FC**/=* *- B*?
;�**=� ** =�� =*   *, =  
 -
* 
* + D?
�� : =* C  :, = = + * 
�*, C- 6*, - D *.
)% :
)%/,! (,66!Q &,3,%,))," 4%(3%(Q )%#(,$-
)%Q 6%( /,%%),Q ',6%)Q (%,Q 4#/,*Q @,),Q 6%(
Nash equilibrium
Q %@JJ,/,
Q %&5)! &+Q %&5)* )%&)-
%)  4,%(! &%+).
3% &! $ )%A )A ) %+%8 $% B, 4(, 3%%B% ',8 
)(# %,% B 4%&6!8 )%*5, 4( %&5)%68 
4,, (*6 4%(#,! %6! 4%(,*8 !&! 4,8
$%&!  '# %,!3 (")," 4%,'%(,,) %&5)!
&+ ,  &!% +(," ) %&5)%" )%&)%)A  4,%(!
&%+)
. (% )R8 $% ', B, 4(, , 'A )%6,, %
%,!3 ("),*3  /*3 %&%%!8 %)4,,* (" , !,,*8
)#5)#A5, %,, %,!3 ("),"  4%,',%, , 
%&S*),,8 3%* %,* %,%+% ("),* @% %)%%" 4(6
#, 4%,%%+,,. * +%)#() % )# +% 4%6%),. %&6!
%,%+% ("),* 4%,'!A ) 6(#%(! %%B,*8 %,
%',A # '%%(" 4, '&% , 4,*,, +%)#()%+%
&A(Q )4%)*A)*  $,%,$)%Q %',A % 6* !&%-
% , 4, J%6,%,, %&&,)),3 +#44Q  (6%,$),3 )3 %,
%',A 4, %%,%,, +(6, )! )%,3 4,).
1' @64,,$), %&%)%%" %,, %,%+% ("),* 4%,%%+,
$)%  &#)* B )#5! %4%)!.
%, @JJ,%+% %)#5),* %,!3 (")," %$
4%)!8 %& @%6 ),()# ,)%,* $%$)8 4%*  +,-
$),3 )%&!,"8  , (%),,". @4%3# +%&,'/,, %%B,* 6(#
)6, , A(6, 5 ) 44A)*8 #)%*A)*8 , % @64,,$-
), %&%)%%+% #$%+% 4%,6,* 4%&6! %,!3 ("),"
4% B,A )%/,!3 (,66 ',), B !,,. %)%# %"
%,, 5 8  %
&3%(,6% )%'(8 $%&! %,  %4%)!= 4%$6#
4*6% %&5, ,/%6  ,/# )+( #4* )%#(,$)% 4, B-
,, )%/,!3 (,66T  )##! 46! )4%)%&)#A ,,
44*)#A @JJ,!6 %,!6 ("),*6T
,66! %',A  %&5)  ),#/,*3 ',6%("),* )*," '8
%+( #% ( !&%= #(%%* , )%, ),A6,#! ,)! '
)$ #3#(B,* 4%%,* )3 #$),% @)4,6 ,, 4,* 4-
,! ,! B,*. , B,, %4%) %& %&5)!3
&+3 K%% ' '+*',6 %#A5" )(!8 (,%- , 4(-
$,8 4%+%' 4%+%(!L 8 % ,3 4%#$A8 )$,A8 $% #$)%  ,3 4%-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
,'%() ,6 (%%+%8 , 4(4%$,A8 $%&! 6)% ,3 4,, ' @, &+
(#+,. ), ) &#(# )(% %" )+,,8 % @,3 &+ ,&% %) 
%))*8 ,&% ,3 &#( (%)%$%.  $% #$),  %&)4$,, )&*
@,6, &+6, !+%(% )6.
%/,! (,66! %',A % )3 )J3 ,',= % 4,*,* -
!3 B," 4% %4%)6 %"! , 6, (% 4,*,* 4%)!3 B,"8 -
)A5,3)* B" 4%)(%" ,',. %/,! (,66! ,6A ',$-
! ',*8 4,6= %(%+% ,, %,%+% &+ KUlson8 9:D;8
V.Wamuelson8 9:;HLQ &'&,, KXdney8 9:7:Q Yrossman and Zart8 9:F0LQ
6%!3 #(%)" 4, !&% B," KZolmstrom8 9:F2LQ 4%&6!
%*!3 %&*') K[illiams8 Collins8 and \ichbach8 9::7LQ %&%&5%+%
)%/,%+% %&6 KXkeh8 9:7HQ Xmerson8 9:72a8 9:72bQ ]amagishi and Cook8
9�::LQ %&5)%" )%&)%),  4,%(! &%+) KY.Zardin8 9:DFLQ
#+%' , )%" %J%/,, K^oulding8 9�:DL. )%6%" # %(%" ,'
)6!3 ,')!3 )%/,!3 (,66 **)* (,66 #',8 BA  
%)%%6 4%,,, KYeddes8 9::HL8 4%,,,-6(#%(,, KWandler8 9::28
Wnidal8 9:F;L8 '%%(, KWhepsle and [eingast8 9:FHL8 #4/! K_iller8
9::2L8 )#5, K\eibenstein8 9:7DL8 )4/,,)!  %&), B" %+%,
KYreif8 _ilgrom and [eingst8 9::HL8 6,,)! K^ullock and ^aden8 9:77L8 4%-
J)%A'! (*, K_essick8 9:�7L8 %A/,%! K\ichbach8 9::;L8 (%6%-
(/! K^oudreaux and Zolcombe8 9:F:Q Zardy ` \atane8 9:FFL , (!" ,' )8
%$%8 %+( %', %4%) % (%,, 46  )%6)%6 (%+%-
)%$%6 &,').
% ,( 5 ) (%,)%,$),3 68 %+(8 $%&! 4%)% !,8 #%
&!% )%65 ,$! +)),! ("),* 4% )6%'5, ) %,!-
6, ("),*6, 4% %&)4$,A %&%%! 4%, %&5+% +8 (%&!$, 4,5,8
%)4,,* (". E,'  )6 , )%6)! ("),* %(),% 4%6%-
+, !, , B )%/,! 4%&6! KZamilton8 9:DHL. %  %%
%()! %%B,* )#,, @%" /,. A(, ), ,  )%%&5)=
6) ',6)* )),6 3%'*")%68 %+% ) (#+,6, )6,8 )%-
, '(,* %&5+% 4%'%,*8 %3* , &$ 4,%(! )#)!
),3%%+,8 )%%,, %,, @%A/,,8 #(A8 $% A(, ',, 
)& )4%)%&%)8 4%(%&#A %"8 $% # 4, ,'#$,, ,%)!3 *'!-
%= #$, %6! ',6%), , %&5, 4, )%/,%+% 4%(,*8 -
%&3%(,6! (* 4%#$,* 4%%,%+% '# % )%6)!3 ("),"
KCosmides ` jooby8 9::2L. $!8 ',6A5,)* 4%&66, 4%',*8
#(A8 $% , $)8  )4%)%&%) 4('*%8 %(%'$%
, 4%% ,',%8 4% )()#  4(A)*8 (* ,3 !&%, %&-
3%(,6! )%%)#A5, ',* , 4,8   (* ,J%6/,*.
%(%6 4%& , %B,&%8 ,)4%'#* )4/,,'/,A8 %%(,/,A (")," ,
',6!" %&6 ',*6, , #)#+6,8 A(, 4,%&A #6,*8 #),-
A 4, , ("),*8 $%&! 4%#$ ,#$B," '#. M,%)%J! #
(% 4,',8 $% 4,%( $% @% )%!" ),6&,%' #(%%,*
+% )%&)!3 ,)% , )4%)%&%), !&! )%, 4, 4%(-
,* ) )%&A(,6 B,3 4,#(,!3 %68 %)4,,66!3  '-
%. % 4%(, )%,%) ,)%,$),8   %% 4%6%+ (%),+
#$B,3 '#% 4, %,%6 ',6%("),,.
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
)%6%" )%/,%%+,$)%" # B,%% 4,' %,* /,%-
%+% !&%. %+)% @%" %,,8 $% ))6,)* ) %$, '-
,* #(%%,* ,6 )%,3 )%&)!3 %)%$!3 ,)%. 1!, )%'-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
%,, #$!8  )%%,, )##%+% %&S*),* 4%(,* A("8
 , )%%,, ,(,,(#%+% !&%8 )6%+# !&% %&5#A %$#
',* ,  4%(% &)4%'! )4%! % %68 $% = )##!
46! ,, ,$! $) A(" 4, !&% B,*.
%-%!38 # #$!3 4()," )3 4%,,$),3 , %%!3
&,%%+,$),3 #8 )#5)#A )%&)! 4%+66! ,))(%,*
4%/)) 4,*,* +#44%" A(" B,* % %
&3%(,6%), %,%+%
("),*. %(4*6* 4,%" %,$)* )36 ,' )%/,-
!3 (,66 4%6%+ &! ,6 %&S(,, #),,*. %)%# '&%, %"
)36! (% $ %/4/,* 4%(,* $%8 )%+)% %%%" 4%*
6%( /,%%), ))6,)* ,B  '%  /4, 6%(" -
/,%%),8   (,)!" )4%)%& 6%(,%,* 4%(,*. %#-
,#A5, #)%, !)#4A  $) )4%6%+%" )##!8 
,( )%,!3 )%8 , ), %-%  )6% %/,  4%%" 6
,3 4,6#5)8 % !&! ,' %#%" ,+! Kwlchian8 9:;0Q Clark8
9::;Q Watz ` {ere|ohn8 9::HL. ), &! ) #)%, 4(4%+, %#-
/,A8 % ,&% #6)%" &! &! %* K4%*L 6%( /,%-
%+% !&%8   ,6% % %&S*)* 4%(,  %#,#A5,3
!3. %(, 4%(,*8 %&S*)*6! %,*6, @%A/,%%+% )-
(,* , )()%" (4/,,8 (%! ) 5 %(,6, ,)#66,
%,$),3 ,))(%,"8 ,)4%'#6!6,  &,%%+,, , )%/,%%+,,.
-,38 #$!8 ',6A5,)* %," 4%',*8 %," @%A-
/,,8 %," ,+8 )%/,!6, , (#+,6, #6,8 +( ,'#$A)* %4%)!
@,),, , %6 4%(,*8 4,6 ',6%),8 # 4%, (%)%$-
% 6%+% ,))e(%," Kwxelrod8 9:FHQ ^oyd ` }icherson8 9:FF8 9::2Q Cook `
\e~i8 9::0Q Yuth ` qliemt8 9::;Q Wethi ` Womanathan8 9::DQ Wimon8 9:F;8 9::7L.
"$)  4%*,) %'6%%) 4%(%, ,))(%, (% 4%#$,*
&% (%" 4%($)%" 6%(, ) /A ,'#$, %,! ("-
),* 4, B,, )%/,!3 (,66.
-$!38 ,' )%6%" +%)#()%" 4%,,,8 %)%&-
% 4%) %)B%" &%!  O(, +(,* %&5)!3
)#)% K9:DFL8 % 6%+%6 ,)3%(, ,' 4(4%%,*8 $% #6! A(,
&)4%6%5! 4( )%/,!6, (,666,8 #*',  ,3 ,  6%+# !-
&)* &' B,3 ),6#% ,, )/,". %+, 4%,,,8  $,3 4%,-
,$),3 4%+663 , @% 4(4%%,8 %',) )4%)%&!6,
B 4%&6! , %% %&%),, ,3 Kwrnold and Campbell8 9:FDQ ^aland
and Vlatteau8 9::DQ _orro and Zull8 9::DL. %,, &#( #)4B%" %-
%  %6 )#$8 ), % ,)3%(, ,' 4%%,* % %68 $% A(, 6%+# #-
$,)* ,)4%'% 3%%B% )%! 4, , (%+%%,)* % )%#(-
,$)8 %,% #$)#*  4,*,, ,3 )3 )A5,3)* B,"
K^erkes8 9:F:Q ^romley et al.8 9::2Q Xllickson8 9::9Q {eeny et al.8 9::0Q _cCay `
wcheson8 9:F7Q _c qean ` Ustrom8 9::;Q Vinkerton8 9:F:Q ]oder8 9::HL.
-4*!38 % %&' +(8 %%!" 6! )%'(6  B,3 #$&,38
4%6%+ )%3* )#5)#A5, (6%,$), ,6!. (% ),
 #$&,3 +( 4()!  4)),! #$),, 4%,,$)%"
,',8  ,* % %( 4%,,6 , $,%,68 %8 '#6)*8 
,3 #$&,3  6% &! %&S*),* %+%8 $% % (6%,*8 ,
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
# %( ) 4 , %&*'%),  (6%,$)%6 +%)#().  ( @%
&#(#5,6 +(6 )! %
&3%(,6% '8 $%&! #6 4,% ("-
)%. O%* 6%+, 4%,%%+, '**A8 $% %,  3%* #$, %6-
,!6 %)%6 (6%,,8  )6%6  ( %, %(* %6! /,,'6 ,
(%,*. ,  %&S*)*A8  6%% ,'& %#4/,,8 )6,*
4%#$ %4(% %+%6! 4,&!,
,, 4%3%" 4%,,,.
6, )%/,* (,66 %%),)*  ',6%',),6!6 ),#/,-
*68 +( A(, (A )%" ',),6!" !&% Kaes8 9:7;8 9:F0Q }. Zardin8
9:79L. % )3 ,3 ),#/,*3 ) %,$)%6 A("
%%! ,6A 4%
( !&% #$)%  ( K
L ,,  #$)% K
L.  ,)# 9
4()% +J,$)% ,'%&, !&% ,,-,,. )% @% !&%
%+%8 )%% (!8   (! ,, .
*- = 1
&     N   
$,)% ,+%%8 BA5,3 %%4,%)* K
L ,,  %-
%4,%)* K
L. ,&! ,+%% K
L8 %%! )%#(,$A8 6B 4,&!-
, )%#(,$A5,3 ,+%% K
L. %,$)," 4%+%' %8 $% ,% 
&#( )%#(,$ , ) ,+%, 4%#$ 4,&!
L. )#B, K
L  )%#(-
,$ ',), % 4%#$6%" 4,&!,8 %%* &%B8 ), !  #$)#B 
)%6)%6 (.
), ) 4,6# #$),  (8 % 4%#$ $,)#A 4,&! K
@%6 (!" )%, 4( ,)#B,6 K
L  %6# 4,6#=  #$),6
,, #$),6  (. %,$)," 4%+%' %= ) )(A !&%
 4,,6 #$),*  %&56 ( ,  (!)*  +%. ),  ,
4%,'%"(8 % '#  4%#$,)*. ',/ 6(# 4%+%',#6!6
'#%6 , %&5,6 (%6  (% !)* ,$,6,
L?K
. %)%-
# 6 !+%(!" '# 3%(,)*  )(,, %),*
Nash
8 % ,%
 6* )%" !&% 4% )%&)%6# ,A8 ( 4, ,$,, !&%
# (#+,3 #$),%. , ),#/,, )%'(A (,66#8   )#5)#
3%* &! %(, '#8 (A5," &%B 4,6#5) )6 #$),6.
8 #$B* , K
Pareto?superior
L )8 %8 )%+)% 4%+%'68
,)% %%4,#A5,3)*
,+%%
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
'(%6!)*5, #$),,8 )( )%" !&% )6%)%*%8  %)4%-
'#A)* A. %J, %', 6(# ,(,,(#!6 , +#44%!6 /,-
%!6 !&%%6. %&6 %,%+% ("),* 'A$)*  %68
$%&! ", )4%)%& ,'& 6 !+%(%" ,! K
Pareto?inferior
, )6,)*  ,&% &+%4,*!6 #)%,*6. 68 %6# -% #()*
)%+)% )+,,8 4%#$A (,,((! %%4% ! ',/
6(# 4%+%',#6!6 '#%6 , 4%#$!6.
4%,,$)%" ,# )#5)# 6%+% 6%(" )%/,!3 (,-
66 KWchelling ` \ichbach8 9::DL. % )3 6%(*3 +#44 A(" A$-
)*  ,+#8 )+,* %%%" )%)%,  %68 $% ),#/,* %),*
Nash
equilibrium
8 4%%* )+% %(, '8  ( )6 #$),6 %4,6-
!" '#. % %), , )
Pareto?inferior
8 .. %), 6-
B+% '#. ), #$),, ,+! )%%4,%,) ) 4%6%5A !-
&!3 )+,"8 %  38 %%! 4(4,)! (* %%4,!3
,+8 % (%),, %4,6%+% '# 6%+% &! &! 4% %'6%-
!6 KZarsanyi ` Welten8 9:FFL. %6,6% @,3 4(4%%," %%),%
!,+!B"  %(%'%%" ,+8 % )3 (#+,3 %J,/,!3 6%(*3 )%/,-
!3 (,66 (A)* )(#A5, 4(4%%,*=
9. (!" ,' #$),% ,6 %&5 4(), %& J,),%%"8
,' )## ),#/,, , 4,&!*38 %%! 4%#$, (!" 4,
)3 %6&,/,*3 )+,".
2. B,* % !&% )+,, 4%(,* 4,,6A)* ,(,,(#%8
',),6% , $)% %(%6%.
�. ),66,$%" ,+ #$),6 4(%)*A)* %(,%! )+,,.
H.  (%4#)A)* B, %! K,, /% #%%()%L8 $%&!
%,  6B, ,+%6 (%+%,)* , ( )%" !&%.
, 4%%,, ,+! %4(% $,)% ' 4(4%+A8 $% #$)-
,, &#(# B 4%&6# 4#6 %&%" ,(#/,, K
backward induction
4(4%%,*3 %%),% %!3 /" ,6A)* )3%(,*.
(%" ) 4(% )%%#4* 6%( 4%(,*8 )%%)#A5-
Nash equilibrium
8 %%% &#( ( 0v %%4/,,8 , 4%(,*8 )%%-
)#A5+% ,#$B6# '##8 %%% )%), 900v %%4/,,.
'! @64,,$), !'%! , %,$), 4%!! *,,) -
'#%6 )!3 4%+%'%. %+%'! (A)*  % %,$)% -
(% 4%,)3%(*5,3 ),#/,"8 $% %%! #$! %&,,)  ',$-
!6 %&'%!6 , @)4,6!6 6,6 ) /A 4%,8 %
!" #% (%&%%!3 %,"  4%,'%()% %&5)!3 &+
K\ichbach8 9::;L. #+, #$! ), 4%%(, &%%! ,))(%,*8
, ,3 '#! 4%', #% %%4/,, 6%+% !B 4%+%',#6%+%
#%*  '%!3 @)4,63. %,6 ,+ &%),, !'%8 ,6 4,B%)
44%, )%, (! !%(! , 4(), %! 6%(, %'6%%+%
%',%,* %,!3 (")," K^enoit and qrishna8 9:F;L.
4%%! ,+! , ( ,( 46!3 $,)% 4%%% , ,4
,+%%8 #$)#A5,3  )%/,%" (,668 $% (% &% %4,6,),$!
4%+%'!. %,$), #)%%8 $%8 %+( %%! #$),,8 )6%(-
,%!  4%%)A /,%! %! ) ,'%" #$%" )%"8
',6%(")#A5,  #)%,*3 4%%*6!3 )%/,!3 (,668 , $* /
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
%&#)% )%3),$),8 4% 6%+# 4%#$, %4,6!" ,, 4%$,
%4,6!" '# , ,'& 4%&(A5,3 )+," (* '%!3 ,+
one? shot
L8   ,+ ) %+,$!6 $,)%6 4%%,"8  (A5,3 %4,-
6!3 '#% K{udenberg ` _askin8 9:FDL. %" '# %'6%
5 , %+(8 %+( ,+%, )6, #),A %),8 B, '
38 % %'!)* % )%#(,$). 4) , (. K9:F2L , 5 %(#
46#A  6%( /,%%),. %4#))* %'6%%) 4%*,*
/,%%+% ,+%8 %%!" %$  )%#(,$)% )%#(,$-
)%68 $% &)%A% /,%!" ,+% ,)4%'#  %)%, (* %+%8
$%&!  $ )%,3 ,+ 4,,6 )+,A %%4/,,8   %-
/ %')* % . %8  %% %(,)* %( ,' @,3 (#3 46!38
$,)% %'6%!3 )&),%!3 ),#/," K
equilibria
L %') 6%+%-
% Kwbreau8 9:FFL. %'6%% 4()' )= %4,6! '#!8
#)%"$,%) ),#/,"
Nash
Pareto?inferior
, ) %)%.
* 4%+%',%,* ),#/," )%#(,$) %,,8 4,6**
)(#A %,A /,%%+% !&%8 )%$, %
&3%(,6!6 (%4#),
! %4(%),8 ,  4%(%,%) ),#/,, ,,
,/,%%) %%!3 ,+%%8 A5,3 %$  )%#(,$-
)% )%#(,$)%6. %8 $% %(, ,+%, ,/,%% !&,A '-
,6%)8 )(%%8 (#+, 6%+# @% )( /,%%8 (%'!8
3%* , (%%% '4#%8 $% ',6%("), **)* %)%%" %6%"
core norm
L8 4,6*6%" A(6,  ),#/,*3 )%/,!3 (,66.
% # )%% ()*%  )%/,%%+, 4%%(* @)4,6! 4%
,'#$,A 4%(,*  ',$!3 ),#/,*3 )%/,!3 (,66. % )-
,A ) (#+,6, 6%(6, 4%, 4%+%'% %)%!3 %,"8 %+( &%-
%! @)4,6! )*)* 4%( )%6,8 B 6%( ,6 /!" *(
4,6#5). %-4!38 6%% %+,'% @)4,6 ) /A 4%-
, 6%+%$,)!3 4%+%'% @%"  %,,  %%,#6!3 #)%,*3.
%-%!38 %'6%% 4%%, %4!. -,38 ), # ,))(%"
%',A )%6,*  (%), 4,6,*  @)4,6 %,-
$), '&%!3 46!38 % %, 6%+# ,'6, ,( @)4,6
, 4%,8  @% 4%,*  '#. % ) ,)4%'#A)* (! -
)%,3 ,))(%),3 +#44. -$!38 6%( @)4,6 &%-
B )+% 4%(3%(, (* ,'#$,* !&%8 %%!" (A A(,  ',$!3
,),#/,%!3 #)%,*3. )%&% ,6, #(*)* )4%)%&6 ,'
, ,'% !6 /%)*6 )#&S% @)4,68 % %%!3 %, )%-
%&5A % 6* %4%). )4,6! 4%'%*A %$% 4%,8 (#
, )&* A(,  ',$!3 ,),#/,%!3 #)%,*3 8  4%+%',%-
%) %," KVlott8 9:70Q Wmith8 9:F2L.
@%" $), * )#66,#A $! 4%)%*% 4%%*A5,3)* '#
,))(%,*8 %4%+A5, )#5)%, %&5" )36! 4%(,* A-
(". , '#! &!, 4%#$!  3%( @)4,6 4% !*),A )%%-
),* %+% 4%(,* A("  ),#/,, )%/,!3 (,66 4%+%-
',%%6# 4%(,A8 4(+6%6# %," % %%4,%" ,+8
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
%+( ,)4%'#A)* 6%( 4%%" /,%%), , 4%* ,J%6/,*
(* %(%!3 , %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*A5,3)* ),#/," ) )%-
/,!6, (,666,.  %&5A %)%&% ,6,  @% )%%), 4%-
(,* , %,, 4%%6#8 $% %,$), 4%+%'! ,B! (#)6!)-
%),. , %', %+%6% ,*,  ',, )%/,%%+,$)%" 6!),.
'#! @)4,6%8 4%%(,6!3 ) 4%(,6  #)%,*3 !%$!3
%%B,"8 4%$, 4%%)A )%4(A ) 4%+%',#6!6, Ka~is ` Zolt8
9�::L. ), &! '%! , %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*6! @)4,6-
! 4%((,, 4%+%'! %,, %%4,%" ,+!8 % %+( 6! ,6,
&! %&%)%#A %,A8 % 6%+%6 %$ &,'#A @%%6,$)%" %,,8
# %%%" ) 6%+#$* @64,,$)* 4%((. 6 )(# %&,)* 
4%&6 %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*6!3 ),#/,"8 (* $+% %,*
%%4,%" ,+!  4%(3%(, ,'-' ),B%6 6%+%$,)!3 ),#-
/," %),*. % '() 6! +%%,6 % (#+%6. % @, '#!=
9. &%B,) ,4% )%/,!3 (,66 %&# !)%," #%
%%4/,,  4%6 @4 @)4,68 % @% #% 4%)%*%
, %4,6%+%.
2. %(,  %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*6!3 ),#/,*3 ) )%/,-
!6, (,666, )%6),6% ) 6%(%6 %&%" ,(#/,,.
Nash equilibrium
 ( (* 4%+%',%,*  ,(,,(#%6
H. A(,  #$ 4, )+,, %),*8 4,6*6%"  4%%*A-
5,3)* ),#/,*3 ) )%/,!6, (,666,.
1. ,            
'# @)4,6%+% ,'#$,* 4%(,* A("
 ),#-
/,*3 B,* 4%&6 )%'(,* , ,)4%'%,* %&5)!3 &+ &!%
%&#%8 $% #% %,!3 ("),"  %(%'%%" ,+ ,, 
4%6 #( 4%%*6%" ,+!  0
. &%B,) )#$ #$),-
, @)4,6 4% 4%&6 #$),*  )%'(,, %&5)!3 &+ 4%)%-
*% (, ),6%,$), (! % H0 (% D0v 8 $% 6%+% 4!B
#%" #% (%  ),#/,*3 %),*
Nash
Ka~is ` Zolt8 9�::8
�. 2;L. (% 4, 4%%,, @)4,6 #% %%4/,, A("
(* )%'(,* %&5)!3 &+ ,6 (/,A ),)*. %(!3
)#$*3 % 6* @)4,6 % 6% &! %$ !)%,6
8 , )(# '-
6,8 $% 4%)%# ) ,6, %&5)*  @% %,(% !)%-
," #% %%4/,,8 %  (,3 ,),#/,%!3 #)%,*38 %+(
 ()* ,J%6/,, % (3 (%+% #$),8 #% %%4/,, 
&! %4,6!68 4%@%6# 4%+%' % #!3 #%*3 %%4/,, 6%-
%  #$,! K3%* %%4/,*  #% , %4,6%+%  (,3
,),#/,%!3 #)%,*3 &A()* 4%)%*%L.
2.     #  #     
     
% )3 4%%*6!3 @)4,63 ,+%, (# 4%)(+% #(
, BA8  &#(# )&*  6 ),. 4%)(6 #(  4(4%+-
A)* &#(#5, ',6%("),*8 , 6%% 4()'8 $% #$),, ,+!
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
)%#(,$  &#(#. %)%# %, BA  4%6 #(8 $%  4%-
)(6 #( )%#(,$ %4(%  &#(#8 % 6%% (%4#),8
$% %,   ), &! %%4,%)* ,  4(4%)(6 @4. -
* %+, &! &! 4,6,6 ,  (,,, '(8  4%6# #(# K\uce
` }aiffa8 9:;78 . :F::L.
% @% 6%( %&%+% (,,* 4,#  B,, '($ ,+!
) %+,$!6 $,)%6 4%%%8 % 4%, +% # 4%*,,) %'-
,* %,$)%+% 3 K^inmore8 9::7Q Zardin8 9::7L. 8  6!
# +%%,,8 )%6,* %%),% 4(4%$,* (#+,6, ,+%6, 6-
%( #)#+ ' #)#+#8  
Nash equilibrium,
6%+# 4%6%$ #$),6 ,+!
)( /,%!" !&%  4%'# )%#(,$)  4!3 @43 4%-
%%" ,+!8  '68  %/ ,+!8 %')* % )%#(,$) Kqreps
et al.8 9:F2L. )4,6! 4%',8 $% ,+%,  #)%,*3 &%%!3
,))(%,"  ,)4%'#A  )%,3 43 , B,*3 6%( %&%" ,-
(#/,,.  %6# 'A$,A 4,B 6% 4%4%  9::7 +.8 4%,-
',% (! )%,3 @)4,6% % ),#/,*3 ) (,666, %%-
),% %&5)!3 )#)%
3. & 
Nash equilibrium
         -
               
+,* %),* 4,+%(  ),#/,*3 (#+%+% ,4  #% ,-
(,,(##6% ,, +#44 A("8 %8  &!% 4%'% !B8 ,(,,(##6!8
)%*5, 4( )%/,%" (,66%"8 %&!$%  4%'#A)* @%" )-
+,". O%* '#! ,3 !&%  )%%#4%), $)% 4,&,A)*  4%-
'*6 )+,,
Nash
8 ,! !&% %(!3 A(" $'!$"%
'%%&'!. %+( % 6* @�)4,6%  200 #(% 4% 4%&6
#4,* %&5)!6, )#)6, +#44! ,' F $% 4,,6, 4(-
,! B,*8 %, , '#  ,)4%'%, #,#A ),66,$-
#A )+,A
Nash
K[alker8 Yardner8 Ustrom 9::0L. , '# %  ,)4%-
'%) ,  4%%!3 @)4,63 4% B,A 4%&6 ,)4%'%,*
%&5)!3 &+ Kudley8 9�::Q saac ` [alker8 9::98 9�::L. (% &!
4%( *( @)4,6%8  ,3 #$)%, 7 $%8 %%! (%!
&!, 4,* %%% 90 B,"  90 #(3. , @%6 %, &!, 4%%)A
,'%,%!8 6(# ,6,  &!% ,%+% %&5,*.   @,3 #)%,*3 ,'
290 %'6%%)"8 4(%)*6!3 #$),6 @)4,68 % 
'6, , %(%+% )#$* ,)4%'%,* )+,,
Nash
K[alker8 9::7L. ^
9::D +.  , (.8 4%%(* @)4,6! 4% !*),A ,*,* +%+-
%), (%3%(  '#! @)4,68 %  %&#,, ,$+%8 $%
6%+% &! 4%(( )+,A %),*
Nash
= )%8 $% '#! -
&%%!3 ,))(%,"8 % %%!3 '() )%%&5%)8 '* 3,'%-
  '#! )+,,
Nash
4. *    %,     Nash equilibrium
    $    #  # 
%+( @)4,6! 4% 4%%(# #4,* %&5)!6, &+6,
,, %&5)!6, )#)6, 4%%*,) %(%% , ,3 #$),,
&!, ,B! %'6%%), %&5)*8 % #% %%4/,, 4(4%(-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
,6)*  )%%# )+,,
Nash equilibrium
. %%! #$! #-
(A8 $% A(*6 #% 4%)% ", 6* , #$,)* 4%'%)* @%"
)+," K\edyard 9::;L. % )3 4%%!3 @)4,63 4%,)3%(,
(%%% '** 4#),#A5* , '#%= #$),, (6%-
),#A %%, )4), #,$,* ,, #6B,* #%* %%4-
/,, ,  %  6* %&5* (/,* ,(  %&S(,,A8 $% )%4(
)% )+," #)%"$,%), Ksaac8 _cCue8 Vlot8 9:F;Q X.Ustrom8 Yardner and
[alker8 9::HL
. 1% %+%8 '! #$),,  4(3 %(%" ,+! 4%-
'#A)* ',$!6, )+,*6, Kudley8 9�::Q saac ` [alker8 9:FFbQ X. Us-
trom8 Yardner ` [alker8 9::HL.
!3%(,8 $% #$),, %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*6!3 @)4,-
6% 4%),+A $% (#+%8 , )+,A #)%"$,%),. % ,
,*6) ),A #% ),,* 4%'"8 4%) %+%8  ,)4!#-
6!6 )',8 $% @)4,6 &#( 4
%3%(, 908 H08 D0 '. % )4-
( %,%), (")," 4%)6)% ',), % $,) #(%. 6)%
%+% $%&! #$,)* )+,, #$),*8 #$),, @)4,6 #$)*
%6#8  (%+%)%$% )%#(,$  )%6%6 #%. %#(,$)%
(%),+ )6%+% ,'%+%8 #%+% #%* %%  )%,3 4%)(,3
#(3 @)4,6.
%%#4!6 !%(%6 ,' !B'!3 $!3 $)% 4%%*A5,3-
)* '#% **)* %,/, 4%+%'%8 )(!3 4% 4%%" 6%(,
/,%%),.  (#+,3 %&5,3 '# ,))(%," 4%,%$
4%+%'6 )%6!3 6%("8 %  %  )6% 6* (%'!A8 $% $-
% 6% 4%#$, '# 6%+% #$B /,%%+% KCosmides
` jooby8 9::HL8 4% "" 6 %+% /,%%+%8 $% '%%  @,3 6%-
(*3. % %!, )%)%,  %68 $%8 4%)% '+%,*8 %(, #$)-
, ( (#+%6# #)%! %&5,* , !), %%B,* (%,*8 
%%!3 &#(# #$)% , %)!. %% %!, 'A$)*  %68
$% )#5)# * %'6%%) B )%/,! (,66! %%+%
4%*(8 %%! 6*A )### (,66! 4%+% 4%*(.
% %,, %%4,%" ,+! )$,)*8 $% ,+%,   )%)%*,,
'A$ !4%,6! )%+B,*
. %@%6# %&5, ))6,)*
4%)%  '+%%. )#$*3 ) )%/,%" (,66%" ',)%!
#$),, ,+!8  %,()*8 &#(# ,)4%'% %&5, ) /A 4%4!-
)* #&(, (#+,3 $ )%#(,$8 (")% )%6)%8 '6
%, %)4%'#A)* )+,"
Nash
8 4,,6* )%&)! B,* K^arry
` Zardin8 9�:F28 . F9Q {arrell ` }abin8 9::D8 . 99�L
. ,8  +%%, ,
,8 4%)%+% %&5,* (%)%$%8 $%&! ,'& (,66
. %-
,$),8 ,$% %&5, #$),% @)4,6  (%% ),B%6 4%-
,*  '#!8 4%#$6! 4, B,, )%/,!3 (,66. (%
%(, ,   '#! 4%%*A5,3)* @)4,6% +%%* % %68 $%
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
4%,)3%(, '$,!" %) #%* )%#(,$)8 %+( #$),6
'BA ,$% %&5,. % 4%(()*  ,))(%,*6, 
&%%!3 #)%,*3 )3 ,4% (,668   '%!6, , %4(-
% $,)% ' 4%%*6!6, @)4,66,. ,' @)4,6%
K&% 900 ) #$),6 ; !). $%L 4%%(,)* @%%6,)6,8 4%,%-
%+6,8 )%/,%%+6,8 4),3%%+6,8 ,8  #( , KWally8 9::;L8
%'6%%),8 )%'(!  '%!3 @)4,63 (* %&5,* ,$%8 
)'8 ) +'#  +'8 '$,%8 &% $6  H;v8 4%!BA #%
%%4/,,. % '$,8 $%8 ), #$),6 (% $ @)4,6 '-
BA 4%+%%,8 @% #,$, %%4/,A  H0v 4% ),A )
4%%*A5,6,)* @)4,66, &' %'6%%), 4%%&5)*. ,,
(#+, 46!  ,6, &% ),%+% , 4%)%*%+% ,*,*  -
'#8 $6 ,$% %&5,. % %%4/,, %))* !)%,68 (
), 4%) (%+% #( @)4,6 %(! #$),,  ,6A
)*', ) +#44%" KCason ` qhan8 9::DL.
JJ,%) %&5,* ',), % #6,* A(" '+%, (#+ )
(#+%6.  , ,)%  9::99::2 ++. 4%, @)4,6 4% 4%&6 #$-
),* A("  )%'(,, %&5)!3 &+. $),, @)4,6 6%+,
)%%&5 % )%6 ,, )%#(,$ $' %64A#A )*'. EA-
5,3 %'%) '$,% 6B8 $6 % 6* @)4,6 ) ,$!6
4,)#),6 #$),%8 3%* 6%(,  %&%,3 )#$*3 4,6*) %(
,   Ksaac ` [alker8 9:Fa8 9::9L. %% , +, K}occo ` [arglienL 
9::; +. 4%%,, )%, 4(!(#5, @)4,6! 4% ,))(%,A )%#(-
,$)  B,, 4%&68 )*'!3 ) %&5)!6, )#)6,8 A-
$, ,( %&5,* ) +'#  +'
. '#  , ,)% 4%((,)*8
.. %64A% %&5, (% 6B A5,3 #$)%  B,,
. J" , %'  )%6 (%(  9:FF +. % %6,,
%)#), )'%" ',/!  '#3 @)4,68 %+( #$),,
@)4,6 6%+, 4%)()%6 %64A%" )*', 4( % )%6 -
6,, )%#(,$  B,, '($8 )*'!3 ) 4(%),6 %&5-
)!3 &+.
))(%, 4(+A )(#A5 %&S*), %)# )%#(,$-
)  '# %&5,*=
9L ,J%6/,* 4()* % 38 % 6% %4(, %4,6#A
)+,A8 68 % @%+% )6%)%*% )(  6%Q
2L 6(# #$),6, 4%,)3%(, %&6 ',6!6, %&*')6,Q
�L #4*)* (%,8 , 6 )6!6 %'!)* ,*,  %,(,
%4(%+% 4%(,* % (#+,3Q
HL (%&*A)* %! /%),  )#&S,%" )36 4%#$,* 4,&!,Q
;L #4*A)* 4(!(#5, %6,! /%),Q
DL )%'()* ,(,$%) +#44 Ka~is ` Zolt8 9�::Q Urbell8 aes ` ~an de
qragt8 9::08 9:FFQ X. Ustrom ` [alker8 9::7L.
5% 4%(+%%! @)4,6! 4%'!A8 $% @JJ %
%66#,/,, (%),+)* ',),6% % 4%" 4,$,!. ), 68 %
 #6 %&5)*8 ,J%6/,* 4% )+,, (%),,* %4,6%+% )%-
6)%+% '# %&S*)*)* *)% , $%8 % %&6 A  ,* 
'#.  %+( %&6 ',6!6, %&*')6,8 #4, (%,*8
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
!&% , #4, %68 )%'(, +#44%%" ,(,$%), **A-
)* ,&% !6, #)%,*6, @JJ,%+% )%#(,$). 6, 
#$),, @)4,6 &#  )&* %&*') !4%* )+,A8
%%#A %, !&%,8 (* 4%#$,* ,#$B+% )%6)%+% '#-
&3%(* +#44! , 4%)* (%+% $ %&5 (#+ (#+#8 $%
%, &#(# 4,(,)* )%6)% !&%" )+,,. %%(,6!
(,)#)),, %&!$% '$,A)* )(#A5,6 %66,6=  4 )
'4%6,8 $% 6! 6) )(6 @% #$B8 ), &#(6 4,(,)*
!&%" )+,,
KX.Ustrom8 Yardner8 [alker8 9::7L. % 6* 4%%-
!3 @)4,6% #$),, #4, 38 %  )%+B)* )(% ,'-
&%6# )6, 4#,8 '!* ,3 B"&36, , .4.
&8  ( + , %) K9:FF +.L  $, 90  4%%(,, '%-
! @)4,6! ) 4,*,6 B," 4% %4%)6 %%),% %&5-
)!3 &+8 , 48 )#66,#* ,3 '#!8 ,))(%, %6$A8
 #,$,%) $,)% ',6% 4%(4*A5,3 4%/))%8 %+(8 4% #)%-
,*6 @)4,68 )% 'B% %&5,
. (% #% #4*
',6% (%,  (6!6 %&5,*68 $%&!  ,'6,,) %,(,*
%4(%+% 4%(,*. , ,$,, )#5)%" ',/!  '#-
3 )6 %*%8 $% ,6% %&5, () 4%#A #%) (%6#
 %68 $% (#+, !4%* )%, %&*').  6! # +%%,,8 $%
%%B, 6(# (%,68 #)%!6 %&*')%6 , 4#/," $%-
8 %%%6# 6%% (%*8 **A)* A$!6, '*6, %,, /,%-
%+% , 6%%+% 4%(,* %%+% 4%%,*.
%+( ), #,$,A , )%,)* #(% %%,% ,(,-
,(#! (!8 %&5, )%,)* 6 @JJ,!6. . )%68
( , %  9::H +. %&#,,8 $% )#&S! 4%#$A '#!8
%$ &,',  %4,6!68 %+( ( (%+% #$), %%),-
% , , ) %'6%%) ,$%+% %&5,*. %+(  '6! (
)#5)% #,$,,) K , 4%**%) ,)#B, %&6# ,  !4%-
, 4(!(#5, )%+B,*L8 % )#&S! (%&,,) +%'(% &%B+%
)%#(,$) % 6* @)4,6%8  %%!3 (%4#)%) %&5,8 4%
),A ) @)4,66,8 +( %%  (%4#)%)8 % )  )%#(,$-
)% &!% 6B,68 $6  ),#/,*3 ) &%B%" )%". #($, (%),$
%,!3 ("),"  4%!3 #)%,*38 +( %&5, &!% %'6%!68
#'!A  %8 $% %&5,* )6%+% 4% )& (%)%$%8 $%&! +,-
% #)4B% %,% ("),.
@)4,6 4% B,A )%/,%" (,66! %'6%% -
' #$),%8 %'!A5,3)* )%#(,$ ,, #BA5,3 )%+-
B,*8 ,'6,6 4, ,+! ,, %+,$,6 ,3 %'6%%), 4%-
'%,* (,6, )#)6,. (%6 )#$ @% &! &! 4,!" !-
&%. , ("),* 4,6*A)*  @)4,6 4% 4%&66 )%'(,*
%&5)!3 &+. $),, ),A)* ) )%/,%" (,66%" %-
%+% 4%*( K%" ,, &%B" )%%),L )*," '8 %+( ),)*
%4%) % 4,6,, (%%+%)%*5,3 )/," ,, ,'6,, 4%*( ,+!
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
KUli~er8 9:F0L. ()'! '# A&%" 4%4!, B, (,66#
%%+% 4%*( &)4%'%8 , 4()',* )+( '$,A)*
#($". (% #$),, 6%+%$,)!3 @)4,6%8  %6 $,)
 4%!3 #)%,*38 ) % @% (A. %+%$,)! ,))(%,*
 %&), #4,* %&5)!6, )#)6, 4%',8 $% )6, #$)-
,, )%'(, , 4,6,, %+%6% %,$)% 4, (* ,'6,*
)##! ),#/,,8 5"  %)% )%/,%" (,66! K^lomuist8
9::2Q ^romley et al.8 9::2Q \am n.d.Q _cqean8 9::2Q X.Ustrom8 9::0Q Wchlager8
9::0Q Wchlager ` Ustrom8 9�::Q jang8 9::2L. , 4, %$ %,$A)*
(#+ % (#+8 %* 6)! #)%,*8 ###8 (,/,, (%+% %-
%+% "%. 6  6 %&5, %)#,! 4,/,4! K
design
principles
L %A 6)!8 +,%! , 6(#%(! ,6!8
)6%)%*% %',B, , (")#A5,  $, 4%(%,%+%
6, KUstrom8 9::0L. 1%B,)% ,' (% )#5)#A5,3 ,6%
%&5)%+% (,* , )4%*,* )#)6, ,6A )%, $,
63,'6! 6%,%,+ , ),)6# )/,"8 4, 4%6%5, %%!3 (%),+-
A)* 4%($,, , )%&A(, 4,. ,6 %&'%68 6%+, )6%)%-
*! ,6! 4%+A)* %% ,B  %&5, (* 4%((,*
)%#(,$) 68 +( ),% ,)#B, #B, ',6! %&*'-
). +,'%!8 %%! % 6%+# **)* #$),6, @)4,-
68 )/,"  %(!6 ,/6  4,6*A8   )6, %, (%
#BA 4,. )%+, )/,, 4,6*A)*8 $%&! 4(#4(,
#B," % %68 $% )%&A(, ,6, 4, '6$%. #B,,
!4$,A &%B%" BJ , %'5A)*  )% )%%&5)% ) 3%%-
B" 4#/,"8 # '*8 $% ' )%&A(, 4, )(# ',.
?%)!3 #B," 4%(+A )'!6 ',*6  ,( ),3
)/," , ,)A$,* ,' +#44!. ,8 %$A5, @,6 )##!6
4,/,468 #4*A )%#(,$)% , #%) (#+,3 #$),% 
%68 $% %, !4%* )%, %&*').
4%!3 #)%,*3 (, %!3 4, %&!$% 4%,)3%(, 4#6
4%& , %B,&%8 '6 )%'()* ),)6 4,8 %%! (A %'6%%)
#$),6 4%#$, )#5)#A $,)#A 4,&! % )%,3 %,".
'-' )%%), %" ,', A(,  )+( 6%+# )'# %4(, 
4%6 , ( %%6 # @)4,68 , 4, **A)* 4,-
!6,. , 6%+% ' &#(# )%B %B,&,  4()'#6!3 ,'-
!3 #)%,*38 4% )6%+# ",  4,8 %%! 4%6%+# ,6 4%#$
4,&!  $, (%%% (%+%+% 6,.  4, #)4B%" %+,'-
/,, ( %'6%! %J,! 6,%+% 38 (* &% @JJ,%-
+% #+#,%,* %%!3 ,%+( %(*)* %! 4, K.Ustrom8 9:F7Q
{eeny ` icht8 9�::L.
%6,6% 4%(,* &%B%+% %,$) @)4,6%  4%!3
#)%,*3 ) /A ,'#$,* 3 ,'6,"8 %%! #$),, @)4,6-
 %)*  )### ),#/,,8 4%%(,,)  ,))(%,* %+%8 
4%,)3%(, B, )%/,!3 (,66 %%+% 4%*(Q 4%)(%-
% (%%(,,) (% %4,6%+% #%* '#! @)4,6 ) (,6-
66, 4%+% 4%*( Kaes8 Urbell8 ~an de qragt8 9:FDQ _essick ` ^reer8
9�:FQ }utte ` [ilke8 9:FHQ Wato8 9:F7Q an de qragtQ Urbell ` aes8 9�:FQ
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
]amagishi8 9::2L. %B,% 6+,B, K9:FDL 4, 4%(,, @)4,6 ,)-
4%'% !8  %%! 3%(,, 4#! )% B%" ,'6,* (%,*.
1% !)%, &! 4% B (%,* 4%#$,,  )#&S!8 $" ( 
4%,'%()% %&5)!3 &+ *)* 20v , &%B. 8 % 4%#$,
,'," & 4% B (%,*8 ,6, %'6%%) ( )#5)!"
(  J%( ',*8 #( 4%)#4, BJ! ' ,6B," ( 
%&5 (%8 4%@%6# , @, #$),,  4%#$, )6!" !)%," &
' #% )%#(,$). % 6* 4%)(,3 #% (%+% @)4,6
%, (!,  )%6)!" J%( %%% :0v. %"  '# &! 4%-
#$ ,  3%( ,))(%,"8 4%%(,6!3  %" 6, K]amagishi8
9:FFa8 9:FFbL. %+,$!6 &! , )(!" !%(= A(, ) ,6B"
B%" (%,* &%B (!,  J%( ,)4%,* )/,"8 &%B
+,%,  )##! ,'6,* ,+!8 , 8 % ,'$% '-
)#, &%B+% (%,*.
% 6* )%,3 @)4,6% X.Ustrom8 [alker , Yardner K9::2L 
4%*,8 3%* , ,3 #$),, ( '%)!  BJ%" J%(. (-
)'!,8 $% $,)% A5,3 &#( *)* 4%$, #A8 $% )/,, 
4,()* 4,6*8   ( %'%)8 $% %!3 &!% 6%+% &%-
. %+( % 6* @)4,6% %&S(,*, )/,%,%, ) %'-
6%%)A %&)#(,* , +%%)%,* ' )%'(, )%&)%" ),)6!
)/,"8 '# 4%)3%(, ) %,(,*. %) 4(%),* %-
% %(%" %'6%%), %&5,* )#&S! )6%+, 4%#$,  )(6 F;v
%4,6%+% #%* ,),/," KD7v 4%) !$ )3%(%  )/,,L.
 ,),/,, 38 % )$,) , %&)#(, %4%) % )%'(,, )%"
)%&)%" ),)6! )/,"8 (%),+�, :v %4,6%+% (8 Hv )%-
), #% 4%+B%)"8 )3%(! 4% )/,*6 &!, '$,!6,8
 $% $,)!" (
%3%( )%)
, :0v KUstrom8 [alker8 Yardner8 9::2L.
_e)), , +% %+, 4%, *( @)4,6% 4% !*,A -
,* )#&S% (")% %,%8 (* %+% $%&! ,'6, ,),-
#/,%! )##! 4( 68  )( !&% % (3  %&5-
)! )#)! K_essick et al.8 9�:FQ Wamuelson et al.8 9:FHQ C. Wamuelson `
_essick8 9:FDL. $)%),8 )#&S6 4(%)*) %'6%%) %-
')* % 4,*,* )%&)%+% B,* %%),% #$),*  ,),-
/,*3  %&5,! )#)! , 4(%), 4% B @% %4%) ' )A
+#44# ,(#. ?6$% &!%  %8 $% A(, A ,'6* 4,
, 4(4,,6 )##! ,'6,*8 %+( %, ,(*8 $% %&5)-
! )#)! ,)%5A)* KWamuelson ` _essick8 9::;8 9H7L8  % )-
%3%(  **)* (%)%$!6 ),6#%6 (* 4,*,* B-
,* %& ,'6,, ,),#/,%%" )##!.
 % $6  +%%* 6 @, @)4,6!T , (%4%*A (! 4%-
!3 ,))(%," , 4%'!A8 $% , %*%) %+%8 $% A(,8
%'B,)  ),#/,, )%/,%" (,66!8 &#(# ,),% )#)!
(* %&%,* , ,'6,*  )##! ) 68 $%&! 4%#$, 3%%B," )%-
6)!" '#. ,  4%((A8 $% , 4,**  )%*5
6* %,* %%4,!3 ,+8  %)% %%%" , 6%( ,(,-
,(##68 , %,* %%4,%" ,+!  6%+# %&S*), , 4()'
4%(,  ),#/,*3 '%!3 ,, %4(% $,)% ' 4%%*6!3 )%-
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
/,!3 (,66.  8 4%)%# %& @, %,, 4%+%',#A @)-
6! '$,*8 %,  %&S*)*A8 , #)%,* ,*A  4%(S6 ,,
),, #%* )%#(,$).
% 4%-)%*56# #(* '($ (* )%/,%%+,, )%'(, 4%)(%-
%" %,,8 )4%)%&%" %&S*),8  $6 4,$, ',$," 4%'-
" #%* )%#(,$) , % $+% ',), +% 4%!B, ,, 4%,-
,  B,, (,66 4%+% , %%+% 4%*(  )4/,J,$),3 #)%,*3
%!3 ),#/,". B, @%" '($, %$ %  %% (* #-
,8 % , (* )%'(,* 4, 4%(,*  ),#/,*3 (,668 4%6%+A5,3
(%6# $%# 4%#$, &% !)%," 4%(#,!" '#. %-
+, )##! 46! ,*A  !&% %!3 ,%/,"8 ,3
4%(%,%) , 4%)(),* ,),#/,%!3 ,'6," Kqnight8
9::2L. %'6%% )%'( 4%)(%#A %,A ,),#/,%%+%
,'6,* ) 4%6%5A %,, ,(,,(#%+% !&%8  4%+%',#A5"
,%/,,. # %* %,* 4(% /,%%+%8 %$)%+%8
%6,%+% 4%(,*.
%(, /,%%+% !&% 4%+% 4%%,* @% 6%5! (,-
+, 4()',"  #)%,*3 )%" %#/,,8 %+( 4%,+!A
8 %  #)4 %)4%'%)* &,"B,6, B,6, /%)*6, )
6),6%" (* )&* 4%'%".  3%* 4%! 6%(, /,%%+% 4%-
(,* )%B% %B,&%$% )6B,A ) %&5" %," 4%(,* $%-
8 #$!8 A$* %8 &#(# 4%(% ,3 ,)4%'%. (% -
4%*8 %* 6%( /,%%), ')#, ,6,*8 4% )%6
% K9:7;L8  %+,$,A5 %&)%*)% 4%%" /,%-
%),. &5* %,* 4%(,* $% )%6),6 )% )6, 6%(*6,
/,%%+% !&%.  ))6, A("  %64)=  ,3 $%6
)6,, ", ,),#Q ) ,3 %B,&6, , %$)%6  +, %'6%-
%+%Q ) ,3 )4%)%&%)A )%'( @,),#8 '%!8 4, , (%&,)*
,#$B,3 '#%.
  A(, %+,$!  )%" /,%%),8 %,  )+( 6%-
+# !& ,' )+% &% )+," )6#A 4%(3%(*5#A (* %%-
+% )#$*.
,', %$ 6% ,3 ),#/,"8  %%!3 6! 6%6 )4%+
4%%" ,J%6/," % %68 , ("),* 4%/,% %'6%!8 -
%" 6%% 4%#$, '#8 , ("),* 4(4,6# %#!.
6%(, 4%%" /,%%), @% %4(!" #% ,J%6/,,
4%)% (%4#))*. ,'!3 ),#/,*3 A(, %&!$% 4%'#A)* @-
,),%"8 ,)4%'#* %4!" ,6, %4!8  8  $)%),8 4-
,%6 &%B%+% 4/ &+%(* 3%%B" /,,  @% '. ,
4,%)* @, 4, ) )%&%"  &%%,A. 4%%*A5,3)* ),#/,*3
A(, 5 #$B 4%),+A @,),#8 .. J%6!" 6%( B,*
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
'($8 ',A5,"
3%($,%)8 %$)%Q 6%(8 '&%!" (*
%!3 ),#/,"8 +( ) %#/,*8 %+( (A)* (%)%$%
&%B, ),.  4%6%5A 4, @,),, A(, !),A )6#A
4%(3%(*5#A (* (%" %%" ),#/,, ,,A 4%(,*. %6,6%
,)#6%" @,),, A(, #$)* '&! , 4,6* %-
6! , 4,. %( %66, * 4%,6A # #AA8 4%%,#A
,, %,/#A8 %/# ("),"8
%%! A(, )%&,A)* 4(4,-
*. %J%( , )%6 K9::;L ))!A)*  @# #AA %/# 
 4%' %@JJ,/,
8 %%!" 4,&*)*  ,'(6 ("-
)," ,, !$,)* ,' ,3
. (%,  9:F: +. )%'( 6%( 4%(-
,* A("8 ,)4!!A5,3 4,*% %5#5, 48 (!*  %%-
," )% )%, )#)! (, &
B" !+%(! (* (#+,38 , (* )&*.
 K9::2L ))!)*  +,#A )6%%/# A("   (%+
 6%+,3 %63 4%(,*  %4(!3 ),#/,*3 A(, #'A (#+
% (#+8 ',6%(")#*  '!3
)%%&5)3 KColeman8 9:
F7L.
6
 4J/,*3 @% '# #)%,* %!3 6%!3 #%%8
. ?$, %@JJ,/,
4%'!8 -
)%% (! %&*') )#&S !4%* %4(! ("-
),* K+%%, 4(#8 ( %&5,L. %) %+%  @)4,6-
% 4%*)* !+%( % ',6%("),*8 $% 6% B,8
$% ,&%8  &#(#56 % )+( &#( ,,/,,% )%6)! ("),*
,&% ,%+( 4!6  ) 4(+ )%#(,$)%8 ),  @)4-
,63 % &! 4)),!6 &A(6.
%)%# ) %6! 4%),+A)*  )%/,%" )(8 %  '!3
##3 %, '!Q (  4(3 %(%" ##! # '!3 A(" %,
',$A)*8   # A("  '!3 ),#/,*3 ,  '% 6*  %(%"
%%" ),#/,,. ) ( 4(4%%,* % 4%(,, A("8 %%!
6% $6 %,$A)* (#+ % (#+=  %(%6 #()*8 $% A(, 4,%&-
A %6!8   (#+%6 $% %, #$)* 4,6* @,),#. %% )$,-
8 $% %6! @%   @,),8 %%#A A(, 4,,6A  #),-
A5," ,3 ,4 4%(,*. ,* %6! 4%(,*8 %(, A(, $,A
,*  4%(, (#+,3.
%( 4,6, * 4%,6A )(#A5= A(,  +#44 )%6)% !&%-
, 4%,6, %+%8 $% #%8 '* ,, 6%% (  %4(!3
),#/,*38   $% #% 4,6* )/,,  68 % @,6 4,6
 )(#. %+(  4, &! %$ #(% !*, ',$, 6(#
#)%!6, , 6%+,6, '(*6!6, %66, 4%(,*  '!3 ),#-
/,*3 , 4,6,8 %%! 4,6*A)* (* (%+% %%+% )#$*.
%,',% @%8 6%% )'8 $% A(, ) 6* #$ %&5, 4,-
 4%(,*8 %%! 4,6,6!  '!3 )#$*3 K. Ustrom8 9:F08 9::7L.
, )%'(A)*  $)!3 )%%&5)3 ,, &% J%6!3 %+,-
'/,*38 +( %, )#  )& (%4%,#A 4%#A +#'#8 !)#4*
 $) '%8 4%%+% 4(4,),*
. , 6%+# )4%)%&)%
#),,A )%#(,$)8 ), ',6! %&*') &#(# $% , %-
!% !!. 3 )#$*38 %+(  '# ("),* 4% 4,6
4,&!, , ,'(, )4(*A)* %6%8 ))$,!  4%',-
,! %6! 4%(,*  4,3%(,)*.
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
4%)%&%) A(" &!)% #), , @JJ,% 4%'%)* @-
,),%"8 %66, , 4,6, 4%(()* @%A/,%%" 4),3%%-
+," K^arko8 Cosmedes8 jooby8 9::2L8 @%A/,%%" %," ,+! KYuth and
qliemt8 9::DQ Zirshliefer and }asmusen8 9:F:L
8 &,%%+," Kjri~ers8 9:79L8 
 6%(*6, 4(%" /,%%), KWelten8 _itzke~itz and hlich8
9::7Q Wimon8 9:F;L. '!)*8 '&%! %+,,! 6%(, (* -
B,* '!3 '($8 A$* %)%', 4%,)3%(*5+% K_arr8 9:F2LQ)%'(-
, %&5,3 +66,$),3 4, &%+% %&5,* KVinker8 9::HLQ #-
,$, (%+%)%$!3 4,%(% ',6%("),* A("  4%/)) B,*
)%/,!3 (,66 KCosmides and jooby8 9::2L. A(, )%*, 4( )%/,-
!6, (,666,8 %+( %)4,!, , '5,5, )%,3 ("8 (%&!,
4,5#8 ,  @%6 4%/)) %, (%*, (#+ (#+#8 &,  )&* #)! %&*-
')8 , &!% @% ' !)*$,  (% 4%*,* '%% Kde [aal8 9::DL.
,6 %&'%68 %4,%) (%)%$% $,)% ),() %6#8 $% A(,
)(#A 6%5#A )4%)%&%) 4%),+ %6! )%#(,$) , !-
&! )%/,! 4,. % ( ,6 %'6%%) 4%#$ 3%%B#A
4,&!8 )4*)* ) 6))%" %',A5,3 )%/,!3 (,66.
%#(,$)% %%),)*  +#44 )+," 4%(,*8 ,)4%'#6!3
 ),#/,*3 B,* )%/,!3 (,66. A( 3%(*= 9L 4%4! !*)-
,* )%) #$),%Q 2L %/ %*%), ) #)%!6, )%#(,-
�6,Q L B, % ',6%("),,  4%" )(,, @)4,6 4, -
,$,, (%,*  &#(#5,6 #)%!6 )%#(,6Q HL %' &% ) 6,8
%  3%$ (")%  $3 )%#(,$)Q ;L ', 38 % 
%4( (%,*. ) %6! )%#(,$) ,6A %&5, )%)*A5,=
A(, 4%',,% +,#A  4%',,! ("),* (#+,3 , +,% 
+,!. %#(,$)#  %)%%" %6 4%(,* %&#$A % )3
%&5)3 K^ecker8 9::0Q ^lau8 9:DHQ Youldner8 9:D0Q Zomans8 9:D9Q Uaktrson8
9�::Q . Ustrom8 9::7Q jhibout ` qelley8 9:;:L.
6* '6,* )+,* ',6%("),* #)#+ ' #)#+# (% ),3
4% **)* 4(6%6 )6%+% 5%+% ,))(%,*. 8 4,68
4%%(*)* ,6,/,%! ,+! 4% B,A (,66! 'A$!3.
%(&,A)* ',6%(")#A5, 4!. %+)% #)%,*6 ,+! #$),-
, (%! 4()* A("8 # %%!3 4% )()# '%%  3-
= ( $%-% )%%&58 ,'&+ )%#(,$) ,, %$ #)#+%"
' #)#+# K.. )$ )%#(,$8  '6 ( %8 $% (#+, (,
 4%)(6 #(L. )%( K9:FHL , 6,% K9:F9L 4%',8 $%8
%+( A(" +#44,#A 8 $% %, #$B ',6%(")#A (#+ ) (#-
+%68 , )% )6, #$),6,8 %+( $,)% @)4,6% (%)%$%
,%8 %+( )+,* #)#+ ' #)#+# ) #)43%6 %)4,,6)* #$)-
,6,8 %%! B 4,(,,) 6%(, 4%(,* ,  $6 
#$)%. '6 +#44! #$),%8  %%%" ,+%, &#(# ,)4!!-
 )+,A ',6%),8  (% &! &%B,68 $%&! ,'& 4%-
/,% %'6%!3 %B,&% ,+%% K^endor ` _ookher|ee8 9:FF8 9::2Q
Zirshleifer8 }asmusen ` }icherson8 9:FFQ ]amagishi ` jakahashi8 9::HL. %-
6! ',6%),8 ))$,!  %8 $%&! 4%6%$ A(*6 4%#$, &%-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
B (,,((% % )%#(,$)8 ',)* % ,* #$),% 4,6-
* %%% ',. ,+ ) 4,% )#%%+% ',* K
grim
trigger
L8 %%% 'A$)*  %68 $% % ,+%8 %%!"  4%6 #(
)%+B)* )%#(,$8 &#( '! (%+% 4% 3%(# ,+!8 %
(',#  %6-% ,' @4%
A(,  4%#$A 4% )()# %! %6! )%#(,$)
&,%%+,$),6 4#6. (% %, )(#A )6,  4%),,A
%68 %%! 4%6%+A 4,* % B,  %J,%" ),#-
/,,8 ',6%(")#* ) 6,8 % ,6 ) ,6, %(, /%),. A&* #-
#* )(8 +( ) , %)4,!)* $%8 $' %(,"8 )B,3
& , ))8 (#'" , #$," ( 6#  /%),8 %%! )$,-
A)* )6!6, +!6,  ## (%+% 6,.  +%%, #@
K9:FDL8 6! #  ()%6 %') 4! ),6)* ) 4%&6%" !-
&%. %(,, % +(A8 % '!A )%,3 ("8 4% #% %+%8
 )(# ',6%(")%8  #),)* 4%%)A. )%6%"
),#/,, %4%,! 6(! )6*)* (%&,)* (%,*  )&8
+(* )#5,38 ), %, )%&A(A %)%! 4,/,4! , %6!
Kqreps8 9::0L.
'#$, 4, )%#(,$)8 A(,  % )3 ),#/,*3 #6A ,3
4,6*. %%! #),A %6!  %$ 3%%B+% 4%(,*.
4,68  %$ 4%*(%$! A(, 'A8  %$ (#+,3  4%&6-
#A ),#/,A8 4%), 4( !&%%68  )6,6 '6 #),)*8 
'4%#$, )#)!8 % )#6 )! )%, ,),! 6,*8 4%(,-
+)* ) 6* 4(  (%),,A )%" /, ,8 %/8 (%&,)* -
), ( (#+,6,. +#44 A("8 )%&A(A5,3 4, ',6%("),*8
, !,8  !*, , ', %&65,%8 6%+# ,)$'#8 ,
#A +#44# +% '%Q )(%%8 %, 6%+# 4%), 4%, %
#6!3 #)"(% ,, 6)!3 %44%',/,%%8 %%! 4%)% %)4%-
'#A)* ),#/,". 1! ),B%6 (%$,!6, %$ %4)%. ,)#),
 +#44 (%$,!3 %$, 6))% 38 % 4,(,)*
4, ',6%("),*.
8 A(, )4%+A ',$!6, %'6%%)*6, 4,6* @,
4,.  )4 (%,* , ,3 , )%#(,$  (%" %-
%" ),#/,, ,*A )##! 46!= A(, 4%-'%6# &%-
A ( )%'(,6 )%" 4#/,,Q %-% ,(  ',6%) %% 
3 )#$*38 %+( ) )," 6%,%,+ ,, &%B* %*%) -
',*Q %-% )%#(,$  4%&6!3 ),#/,*3 %% 4%%6#8 $%
4#&,$%  @% )%+),)* , 6# 4%,,8  %6#-% +$ '*, % )&
 % $%8 %%!" (%* (#+,6 (% 3 4%8 4%  #,(,8 $%
%B,&)*8 ,  %6 )#$ )*% )%#(,$)% 45)* , %%B-
,* 43%(*  J'# ',*. %  %& @%6 4,B#  "&8 O%J6
, 6,= (%'%* ,+  &%%!3 #)%,*3 @% %% %(% '-
%  /4, )" ,',8   %(!" @)4,6 ) /A ,'#$,* 4%-
(,*8 %%% '% )3%(,)* ) 4,6,8 #6!6, 4%6.
(%%8 6! 6%6 %,(8 $% A(, &#(# 4%+)*  4,
',6%),  @)4,6!3 #)%,*38 %% ), %,  #,(* 
4%/)) #$),*  @)4,68 $% ',6%) '!)*8  (#+,
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
,(! 4%(,* %'+(A)*. %6 )#$ %, %'!A)* %
)%,3 ,),,!3 4%&#(," , 4%&#A (#+, )+,,8 %%!
,6 &%B 4%(3%(*. (, A(" )+( "()* %-%8 % 4%'#)*
%(%" ,' )(#A5,3 3 %6 ',6%),8 %'B,)  %(%% 4%-
%*A5")* 4%&6%" ),#/,,
9. )+( )%#(,$" 4!6Q 45" )%#(,$)%8 ), (#-
+,  %$A 6 Q '!"8 ), %'6%%8 38 % #%*-
)* % )%#(,$).
2. $," )%#(,$8 %% ), )$,8 $% 4# 6%% (%-
*Q 45" &%8 ), (#+,  )%#(,$AQ '!-
"8 4% %'6%%),8 38 % %'!)* )%#(,$.
�. ), )%#(,$)% #)%% (#+,6,8 A$")Q 45"8
), %,  )%#(,$A ,  '!A #%,)%.
%% (%&, 5 , 4,=
H. ,%+(  )%#(,$".
;. ")#"  )%%),, ) 4,6, 9 , 28 % 45" )%#(,-
$8 ), 6%% ) #)43%6 4%,)* ' $#%" )$.
D. )+( )%#(,$" @% " (% 4,% (* )3 ##.
%,$)% )%%%B, A("8 %%! 4,(,A)* %(%+%
,4 4,8 6*)*  ',),6%), % +#44! A(" , ),#/,,
. %8 -
)%% ',6%) !+%(8 ',), % %,$)%+% 4%'* ,/ 
+#448 4%'#A5,3)* @,6 4,%6 ',6%),8 , % ,3 )4%)%&%), %4-
(* $,)% 4(4%+6!3 #$),% ',6%("),*  %%" ),-
#/,, ,  %% 6*. ), 6%+% A(" ,)4%'#A 4#A J%6#
',6%), )+( )%#(,$" 4!6Q %+( (  4%%*A5,3)* ),-
#/,*38 %+( ) (#+, %&)%*) #$! , %/!8 )%#(,$)%
6% 4,),  3%%B,6 '#6. (% /,%! A(,
%,(A8 $% (#+, 4(% /,%! &#(# 4,(,)* (,-
),J,/,%%), @,),,8 %6 , )+," ,  &#(# ,) 38 %
4%'#A)* ,B %(%" )+,". )A$, )%)*A )#$,8 %+( 
4%/)) ,),#/,%%+% %&% %', 4%&%)  A(*38 %%-
!  ,5# %4,6!3 )+,". ),/,,  !*, 6,"
(#+,3 ,/ ##$BA )%&)! '#! #$),% ',6%("),*.
 )%, (#68 $% (#+,  4%,6A8 $% #% &! /,%!68
$%&! ,)4%'% %6# ',6%), Kqreps et al.8 9:F2L.
! &%%!3 ,))(%," ),()#A % %68 $% (%-
%% &%B% $,)% A(" 4%'#A)* 4,6, ',6%), ( 
#)%,*3 4%(%,!3 @)4,6% K_cCabe8 }assenti ` Wmith8
9::DL. ) (!3 &! 4%#$  '# 4%(,* #,6,-
!3 ,+. ,3 ,+3 (#6 ,+%6 4(+A '(, %%#A
)#66# (+. !" ,+% 4(+ )( @% %%6# ,+%#8  %
(% B,8 4,,6 4(%, ,,  4,,6. ), % )%-
+B)*8 % (+, (*)*8 ), %'!)*8 % %& ,+% ,$+% 
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
4%#$A. ()'!)* %'6%% #+#,%, K
equilibrium
L ),#-
/,,= 4!" ,+% 4(%, 6,,6#A )#66# %%6#8 , %8 )(%-
%8 4%#$, 3% $%-%. % 4()', %(%% J),-
J,/,%%)8 $,* ) &% A8 6,&+ , / K9:F2Q {rey
` ^ohnt8 9::DQ Yuth ` jietz8 9::0Q }oth8 9::;Q Wamuelson8 Yale ` ^inmore8
9::;L
. ,/8 4('$! (* 4%" 4%',/,,8 )+( 4(+A
(+ &%B 6,,6%" )#66!Q $5 )+% %, 4(+A 4%(,
(+, )4(,%. ()*A5, %#A 4%',/,A %&!$% %'!-
A)* % 4(%!3 )#668 )$,* ,3 '$,!6,. ,*, ,,
%' % 4(%!3 )#66 ',), % ),)6! /%)"8 4,'%"
 '!3 ##3 K}oth et al.8 9::9L. ), %' 4,* 4(%!
(+, 4%,%$, %)%%6# 4,/,4#  4%%" 6%(, /,%%-
),8 % '#! @)4,6% )* 4%( )%6, @64,,$)#A 4,-
+%(%) 6%(,  (!3 #)%,*3.
* %&S*),* @,3 %!," 4(+%) )%% +,4%'8 A-
$* +,4%'# ',* , +,4%'# ,'#$,*.
,4%' ',* **)*8 4% )#,8 +#6%6 ',6%),. 4%,-
%4%%%) +,4%' (4,%+% ,'#$,* ', 4,4,)! %-
%6# ,,/,%# ,+! 6%, %')* % %+% ( (+8 #-
(*8 $% ( % @%8 $%&! ' 4%+% ,+% ' )4(,!"
'(. # (%') )%)%,  #(,,8 $% #$),, @)4,-
6 )%!  +,%" ',6%), K ',6%6# +,%6# %%B-
,A  )%#(,$)#L. ' ) * )%%)8 % 4!6 ,,/,%6
)(# ,'&+ 4(%,* % %6 '( )#66! (+ ,' %4),*
%))* %%&5 , ) $6 Kwbbink et al.8 9::D8 DL.
&&, )% )%,6, %+6,  4%)%, @)4,68 $% 4()-
', +,4%' %&#$,* , ',* &!, )%B% '!6, , +,4%'
',* 4%#$, &%B#A 4%((#. ! #,(,8 $% %! ,,/,-
%!  ,+ &!,  , ' B, )%!  %' % %+%
'(,* (+ ,8 (* @%8 '!,8   +(,8 4%+% ,+%
Kwlbrink et al.8 9::D8 9;DL. (%%8 %! ,,/,%! ("),-
%8  %'%)8 '!A 4!3 ,,/,%% ,+!8 4(+A5,3 -
!" '( (+.
'# '%%+% @)4,6 4% B,A )%/,%" (,66!
)(! 5 ( %!,*8 ),()#A5, % 4%($),3 %-
%)*3 ,)4!#6!3. %-4!38 8 % 3%* )%#(,$  %6 @)4-
,68 %,(A ',6%("),* ) (#+,6,  +%'(% &%B" )4,8
$6 8 % 3%$ +% ,'& Kaes8 _cja~rish
Whaklee8 9:77Q aes8
rbel ` ~an de qragt8 9:FDL. %-%!38 %+( (% !&,  #)%,*3
)%/,%" (,66!8 %  % 6! )%#(,$8 4%**A &%-
B ,* $ ',6%("), KUrbell ` aes 9�::L. , ,$,,
@,3 (#3 (/," 8 % !)#4 ' ("),*  ',6!3 $3
reciprocators
L8 %* )+%8 &#(# &% %4,6,),$!8 (*) ",
A("8 4,(,A5,3)* %(,3 ) ,6, %68 , %3% &#(# 4,,6
B,*. , @%6 %&* )*' % @,3 (%&%%!3 (")," 4(%-
), #&(,! (%') %+%8 $% &! 4,* %68 ("-
)#A5* # (%)%$% 4%(%,% 6*.
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
 '!3 A(" '! )%%),  ',6%),8 3%* '#! ,)-
)(%," (%'!A8 $% '$,* $) ),*8 4,$%+%
 #$),A  )%/,%%+,$)%6 @)4,68 #  %68 $% )(, ,3
) 6%+% 38 % )+( +%%  )%#(,$)#  ',6!3 $3 (
 '%%68 %%%6 @)4,68 &' 4(,%+% %&5,*. 8
(%%% &%B* $) #$),% !  , ' 38
% %'!)* % )%#(,$)  %&56 (. , 4%),+A)* ,'
4(!(#5+% %4! K)%/,,'/,,L , 3%(*)* 4%( ,*,6 ),#,!3
46!38 ),)6,$), (A5,3 '! 4%',  '!3 ,(3
@)4,6. % #%), ,8  )(),8 #% %%4/,,
6%% 4%(*8 4(%), #$),6 %'6%%)= 9L ,()* K{rey `
^ohnet8 9::DQ Urbell ` oes8 9::9LQ 2L !&,= #$)%  @)4,6-
,+ ,,  KUrbell ` aes8 9::9Q Urbll8 Wchartz-Whea ` Wimons8 9:FHQ
Wchuessler8 9:F:Q ]amagishi8 :FFcQ ]amagishi ` Zayashi8 9�::DLQ L '(, 4%-
%# )3%(!8 ), 4%&#)* 6,,6* )#66 (%&%%!3 (%
 %&5)% &+%Q HL ' 38 % 4%, ',6%("),* Kwbbink
t al.8 9::DQ _cCabe8 }assenti ` Wmith8 9::DLQ ;L %&5)* 4%)()%.
"),*  )%%),, ) 4,%6 ',6%), )4%)%&)#A 4%*-
,A # A(" ),6#  %6#8 $%&! 4,%&), 4#/,A 38 % #6
!4%* %&5,* , )4%)%& %&, %)%$! )3%(!  (%+%-
)%$! (
%3%(! Kqeohane8 9:FHQ qreps8 9::0Q _ilgrom8 orth ` [eingast8 9::0Q
_iller8 9::2L. ,6 %&'%68 A(,8 (%)%"! (%,* , (%*A5, (#-
+,68 ,6A5,6 #A  4#/,A K, ,'&+A5, &+%(!3L8 6%-
+# (%+%%,)* % ',6%!+%(%6 )%#(,$)8 4#) ( %(%'$-
%6 ,  ,B%6 4%&68 ,B &! #$),, ,6, 4#/,A A("8
#6A5,3 ( )%, %&5,*. 1+%(%)8 #6, ' 38
%  !4%* )%+B,"8 * 4#/,* /!" 4,.  %$,
',* ("B,3 %%B," % )B,* )J# 4,+%(%),8 .. #-
,$, $,)% A("8 #6A5,3 ), )&* 4% 4,6 ',6%),. '-
, (%,  )( @% % )%'(, 4, K^raithaite ` \e~i n.d.Q
{ukuyama8 9::;Q Yambetta8 9:FFQ Vutnam8 9�::L. %, @% %,(,
%(%+% $%8 $% ("),* (#+,3 A(" 4%,*A  +% !&% ("),*
B8 $6 ,3 ("),* )# ,')! Kasgupta8 9::78 ;L. %)
B,* )%/,%" (,66! (%, ,*  , $% $
)%#(,$)% ) )$%6  ',6%("),. A(,8 #%%()#A5,)*
/,%!6 4%(3%(%68 ))6,A ),#/,, ) %$, ',* %'6%-
%), ',6%("),*8 ,)4%'#* #6,* , !,8 4,%&!  '#-
 %&'%,* , %4!.
(%%8  %)% &,3,%,))%+% %&S*),* , )*'
6(# (%,68 %%% $% ,)4!!  468 #),,68 4,-
(!6!6 46,8 $%&! )%'( )& 4#/,A &+%(%),8
, %*%)A8 $% #$),, @)4,6 &#(# 4,6* %6! ',6-
%), K)6. ,). 2L.  @, ',6%%%B,* %'!A ,*, )##-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
! 46!8   4%B!" %4! #$),%. 4%6 # @)4,-
6 ) 4%%*6%" (,66%" #$),, ,,/,,#A ,,  ,,/,,#A
%%4,% 4%(,8 ,)3%(* ,'= )%&)!3 4,Q )4, )%"
#%),  %68 $% (#+, &#(# ',6%(")% [email protected] #%)
%)%!)*  ,J%6/,,8 %%#A %, )%&,A (#+ % (#+LQ ,*-
,*8 %'!6%+% )##!6, 46!6,  ,3 )%&)% 4%(-
, ,  ,3 %,(,* %4(%+% 4%(,* (#+,3.
*- = 2
)   $ 
), #%, )%#(,$)  4!3 #(3 @)4,6 ),-
% !)%,8 % A(, 6%+# #$,)* (%* (#+ (#+# , 4,,6 4,
',6%),. ,#$B," '# 4%#$)*8 %+( &%B $,)% #$),-
% 4,6* %6! ',6%), , 4,%& 4#/,A &+%(!3
4%. ,6 %&'%68 #% (%,*8 ',6%), , &+%(%),
)#5)% 4%!B)*. ))%8 ),, %(%+% ,' #'!3 4%-
'" (  ),,A %&5+% %.  %&S*)** 4*6#A #%,
)%#(,$)8 (!" 4%(3%( ')* ) )*'! )##! 4-
6! ) #+%,%6 ,' (%,*8 ',6%), , 4#/,,8   %,8
 )%A %$(8 ,*A  #% )%#(,$) , $,)#A 4,&!.
$,(%8 $% 4, ,$,, %,!3 %%B," %(%-
% ,$% %&5, )#5)% 6* )### ),#/,, KX.Ustrom8
Yardner ` [alker8 9::H8 9::L. ), %(, #$), @)4,6 ,6 %'-
6%%) 4%+%%, ) (#+,6,8 % % 6% %/,8 )%% ,6 6%-
% (%*8 , (%&,)* 4%)%+%8 %+,$%+% #)%,*6, )%+B,* %
)4, )%6)%+% ("),* , )J +% 4,6,*. %6 %&#)%-
%6 )%+B,, 4! %&*'#A)* ),
)#)%  %&5 (%
4, #)%,,8 $% (#+* )%% )(
(. @% )%+B, 
%&*'% A$ )38 % 4%#$, !+%(# % +%. (
 %&5
(% 6% &!  ,8 $% '6 4%#$6%" 4,&!, &#( (%)-
%$8 $%&! 4,$  #$),A %)!38 4, #)%,,8 4(8 $% %,
% )%+)%, )%, ("),*.
&5, )4%)%&)# K,,  )4%)%&)#L (%,A  (#+,6 A(*68
,3 &+%(%),
. ), ) )(!)* #($%8 % #$),, 6%+# 6-
* )%, 4%$! %,(,* %+%8 $% (#+,8 %'6%%8 %)4%-
'#A)* 4,6, ',6%),8 (% &%B" #%),  %68 $% (#+,
4#/,*
%,
% )%#(,$)
,)* 4,&!
',6%)
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
)6 %*% %* (%,6 , ,6 )%#(,$. ), #$)-
,, ,6A ! 4, , %($#8 % )6!6 4%)!6 B,6 &!% &!
4%%# '(, )A )#66#8 %%#A %
&3%(,6% %,8 , 4%()$,
%3%(. ),  (! !8 % '() (%&,)* )%+),* #(8
3%* 6%% ,)4%'% '! 4, )4(,%),8 $%&! )%,
6* , #),,* , 4,",  %&56# )%+),A KZackett8 udley ` [alker8 9::;Q
Zackett8 Wchlager ` [alker8 9::HL.
)%+B,* 6%+# &! A$! , 6! ',* (* 38 % 
)%#(,$ K\e~i8 9:FFL. %&)% ) (#6* #$),6, '!8 )%-
3* 4#/,A8 4%((, )%#(,$)% +%'(% +$8 $6  %&-
)% )
%,$)%6 4%
. ?() ),#/,* %$ %4(-
*. $ #(% 4% '#68 %%! %',) 3#8 $6 %,(%)8
%4(,8 % ,  )6%B,$= %(, , %&6#  6%+% ,, )%%
$% %&6#, 4%6%+#Q )%B, , %-,&#( %B,&# ,, #$)%-
, )8  B** )#$"* 46* ),', %,(6!" '#.
1' %&5,* @ 4%&6 #)#+#&*)*8 % A(, 6%+# 4%( ' % -
,, )%#(,$ )%,6 4%(,68 % &' )*,3 %!3 %,&#-
/," ,6 %&'%68 ,$" 4#/,, ,$%  #+%.
%+( #)% )%+B, (%),+)*  %(%" +#44 ) $,)%6 #$)#-
8 % ) ("),* )(#A5" +#44! &#(# 4(4,,6)* 
%) @%+% )%+B,*. ), (!" &#( )%&A( #)%,* )%+-
B,*8 % ,%" ("B" /,, % %+%8 % &#( ',6%(")%-
8  &#)*. ),  )%+B,  )%&A()*8 % %+( %8 %
)%&A( 4,% ',6%),8 (% 4,6, 6# ',*  %6#8
% )%, %&*') #B,8 4, @%6  &#)* 4(,%+%
)%+B,* %%),% ,'&,* ,( )/,". /,*8 %%#A $)%
4,6*A8 '!)*
grim trigger
)," 63,'6 %'("),*. $)-
, ,+! '4#) )+,A %),*
Nash
, )  4%6%5A !**
A&% 6%B,$)% , %&6. $),, 4%%*6!3 @)4,6%
%&)#(A8 #% , 4,6* @% )," 63,'6 ',* ' 6-
, 4%)#4,8 , $)% %'!A)* 4,6* +%8   4%)(A
)8  %% ,%!" KX. Ustrom8 Yardner8 [alker8 9::HL.  )%
', @% 'B*8 %)%%* /,*. ,6** @# 4%,,#8
#$), ,+! +,#  '$,% %%, % #)%," )%+-
B,* %)%%%8 '% K ,%+( ,  +,#L. ), #B,*
4%(%A)*8 % %+( 4%)4% 43%(* % 'B%" /,, 
)+,, %),*
Nash
K)6. 6 8 p. 9::200L.
) )%% 4,$, 4,6* @# 6# ',*  4#A J'#
',*  ),#/,, ) %,$)%6 #$),%
8 6,,6%" ,),#-
/,%%" )##%"8 %)#),6 %&%" )*',  4 ,(,,(#-
!3 (%. ), 4%,)3%(, %% '$,% %%, % #)%,"
)%+B,*8 % ',6%(")#A5 &%B,)% #$),% ,)4*
),#/,A. ")#* )%+)% (%+%%#8 $% 6 )6!6 #4* )%A
4#/,A 3%%B+% %%4%8 4%((, !)%," #% )%#(-
,$) , 4%6%+ !), ),#/,A  )%%),, ) (%+%%%6.
,6, )%+% ',* )'# 4,%(,  %)&,A )%+B,* ,
 ("B6  '$,%" 4% (
%3%(%. $ #% 4%))*
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
!*,8 % #B )%+B,8 )( 6# #)% '6$,8 #&(,
+% 4%(% )%#(,$ $)% , )( !%( % %'6%%), (-
"B+% )%#(,$) ) ,6 $%%6
. ,6 %&'%68 4%*8  (%-
,8 ',6%) , 4#/,* ,*A (#+  (#+8 6%% %&S*),8 4%-
$6# 4%%*6! @)4,6! ) 4*6!6 ,$!6 %&5,6 (A %"
4%%,!" '#. %+B*) )%#(,$ , '** (#+ (#+
 )%" &+%(%),8 A(, )A)* #4, (%,  )&  4%-
/)) )%#(,$)8  ',6%) )( 5 &% !+%(%" )+,".
?%)%,8 & '!A)*  &%B%" +#44 (!6, BJ6,8
 'B% +,#*  #B,*8 6%+, +#44! 6%+# (%&,)* !)%%-
+% #%* )%#(,$). , '%!3 )$3 (%,  +#443 (%)-
%$% !)%%8 % ), ) )6%+% $ %-,&#( ,' +#44!  4%**
,* )%#(,$8 % 4%,*  ,3 # %'6%%. A&! J!8
),()#A5, % ,'%6 #% )%#(,$)8 4%(!A (%,8
#)%,B)* 4, 4%" )$8  (#+%" %'6%%), %))%, +%
,, 4%+%%, ) #B,6 . "$) )% 4%*8 4%$6# %64A-
! 4%),*  ,6A %" ),!8 #A ,6A ,$! )$, , &)(!8
% 6* %%!3 6%+% 6%% 4%* 4% !,A ,/ , %# +%%).
%@%6# )%'( 6%)J# (%,*  +#448 +( A(, ),,) 4!
, (%! 4,,6 B,* ',),6% (#+ % (#+8 %$ #(%8 ,%-
+( 4%)% %'6%%.
)%" ) * 4!) 4%'8 )%% %
&3%(,6% )"$) &%-
 ( )%'(,6 %!3 6%(" /,%%),8 $%&! ),)6,',%-
 ) 4%#$! 6,  '# @64,,$),3 ,))(%," ',*
%%),% )4%)%& B,* )%/,!3 (,66.  )$,A8 $% 6)%
%+%8 $%&! )%'( %#A %J,/,#A 6%(8 )(# ,(,J,/,%-
  4,',8 %%! %"(#  %J,/,! 6%(, %&S*),* 4%-
(,* $% 4, B,, )%/,!3 (,66. ,6, 4,'6, **-
A)* (%,8 ',6%) , 4#/,* K)6.= ^oyd ` }ichardson8 9:FFQ Yuth `
]aari8 9::2Q oak ` Wigmund8 9�::L.
@%" $), ), * !),A %,$)," )/," %+%8 
B, [email protected]'%+!L 46! %&S(,*A)*8 $%&! 4%,*  #-
, [email protected](%+!L )##! 46!8 %%! )*'! ) %)%-
!6, @66, %,!3 %%B," K)6. ,). 2L. ), ) )#-
#! 46!  %(%" &%B%" 4,$,%" 6%(, %'6%%8 
 )#5)# 6%+% !3 46!38 ',),6!3 (#+ % (#+ , ,*-
A5,3  '$, (#+,3 46!3. #(% )%'( 4%)(%!"8
)%%#4!" %,$)," )/,"8  %)% %%%+% &#(#  4%-
)! 6%(,. %+(8 ,'6** #A-% %(# 46#A8 6%% &' %/
,))(%8 $% &#( 4%,)3%(,. %'% 6 (%' @% ) 4%6%5A
%,$),3 ),#/,".
$6 ) 4%"8 %%* (% 4,),  )%#(,$)#8 @% +#4-
4 ,' ()*, J6%8 (A5,3 J66, 4,&,',% %(%+% '6-
. % ,3 '6*6 4% &%B* 8 %, ) A 4%'#A)*. (!"
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
+%( # ,3 %', %( ,   4%&6 !(, %(, &%$," ( (*
%,%" %$,), ,%,, % 4%!3 ( , 4%B%+%("
%4B" ,)!. , %(, ,' ()*, J6%  (#6 45 ',-
6)* )),6 3%'*")%6. " 4(4%%,68 $% %,$)% %(! 
@%"  ',), % %,$) ("8 !(!3 J66,   %$,)#.
% J6! 4%#$ &%B 4,&!,8 4%(%* &%  )%,3 J638
, %$,5* #. %@%6# (!" ,' ,3 3% &!8 $%&! (#+, 4%&%-
,  %$,)8  )6 #,# % @%+% (. (% / #$),* (%-
+% J6  %,%" &% !B8 $6 )3%(! 4% %$,) ,.
 4 (" 4%)6%,68  %%! )##! 46!
,*A  %'6%%) %+,'% )%6)#A &%�# K)6. ,). L. ),
+#44 &%B*8 % )%)6 #(% %+,'% ,$#A )$# , 4%-
+%%,. %+%%,)*8  )4(,% )4(, &%# 6(# )%&%"8
&!% &! #(%8 4%)%# ,)! # ,3 %&5,8 ( , J6! 4%$, %(,-
%!. ,", (%  %(%6# 4%)%6# B,A '$, ( #&%-
,8 %+( (!" #& #$)% ,  )%" ,%,,. , %&)#(,,
@%+% %4%) #% 4%($# %) #$),* )3 J6%. ,$-
!3 )$3 %,8 %$%8 4%)4,$A % 38 % B  4,,6
#$),  %&5" &%8 &#(# #&( ,3 &%B   (8 6%+# (
4,+%',8 $%  &#(# !(* &%$,38 ), %,  ,)4*)*. ),
+#44! &%B, , %(%%(!8  4)4,! '!  4%,'%(-
)% %&5)!3 &+  $, 4%(%,%+% 4,%( %%),%
6!8 % 6! 6%6 ) #%)A 4()'8 $% , &%B* +#44 A("
"( )4%)%&8  6) B, )%/,#A 4%&6#. % (%'!A 
%% &%%!8 % , 4%! ,))(%,* KX.Ustrom8 n.d.L.
*- = 3
    
+/*056
*+(/89
&(0+*786/&0
6&0
�=68(&09
% 4%B!3 ("),*3
!  8= 
G )%+B,*
,66,$!
+ 
?# 
%+%)%$!
4)4,!
4%,'%()*
J#/,*







. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
% +#&*8 % 4%)(%* %,* 4,$,!3 )*'"8  %%%"
,)4%'#A)* )##! 46! K
B [email protected]  +,   C?
*+�  - =6*,  /  C�C=*� , **/ �8 = C*?
� * -
L (* 4()',* ) &%B%" )4A %*%), %+%8
$% #$),, )6, 6%+# B, (#A )%/,#A (,66#. '6,*8
( )6! '$,!8  A&%" ,' @,3 46!3 ,*A  %$-
%) 4()',*. 4,68 4(4%%,68 $% (#+%" 6)!" J6
4%#4 ; #$)% '6,.  3%$ %&&! ,3 , ))$,! @,6
',6)* (%+% 6*. %+(  @%" 6)%), &#( %% D J6%8
%(, ,' %%!3 ( 4%%,%" 4,.  ), @% J6 )(#
4,#8 $% 4% )4(,% 4,,6 #$),  &%8 %%* (-
)* (* %&5+% &+ , %'+()* )%%)%8 % #,$,
+%+%),  &#( 4%(%,6%" 4%&6%". , )%+)*)*8  @%
, 4%,)3%(, % )6 6,8 4,,6 #$),  )%6)%6 ( 4%4%/,-
%% %,$)# '6,8 %%%" %, (A. ),  # %%+% J6
,! 4%*,* % )4(,%),8 %+( # &%B%" +#44! 6% 4%*,)*
&% )'* 4%&68 $6 # &% #4%"  ),#  #,$%" +-
%+%), K&%B," )%) +#44!L.
 4 4() )&8 $% @, #$), '6, 4,%&! 6)!6
')%"5,%6 4%( )%,)% '+%%(!3 %(". 6* %+,$%8
%)%&% (* (%  ,,+/,A.  %$, ',* ')%"5,8 %  &'-
&,,8 % 4%)%  ,(, (* )&* ,%" !+%(!  %$,) ,. 8 -
,6 %&'%68 @% ,'6, 4%$ /!" *( (#+,3= ,'6, %,$-
) #$),%  +#44Q )3%(, ,)% , )()Q ,$, %(%+%
#$),8 (A5+% 4%%,%" )#)%8 %   (%+%)%$#A 4)4-
,#8 ,  ',)%%+%  (8 !+%(%6 (* )3. % 4,6 4%'!-
8  ,'6,*  %(%" )##%" 46%" !'!A 4%)(%-
% ,'6,*  (#+,3 46!3 , )%% #(% )%, 4%)!
(#6! +,4%'! % %'("),, %(%" 46%"  #% )%#(,-
$). (%6 )#$ &%B %*%) %+%8 $% %%4,%)* &#(
&%B* +#44 ,' 90 J6% ) %(,%!6, 4%'*6,8   6*
,' D $%. ),8 @% !%( 4%%)A 4%,%$, %&54,*%6#
'+*(#  ,*, '6 +#44!  #% )%#(,$).
!%(! 4% '&%6 6%(" %%+% 4%%,* (* 4,*,* @6-
4,,$), %&%)%!38 4(% /,%!3 , 6%!3 B-
," )6 '$,!. "$) 6%% &% ),)6% ), )%!
#$%-,))(%), %4%)!. 6 #% 4,*  %%#, ,4
,))(%)%" 6%(,,8 ,)4%'#6!" 4%,%%+,"8 4,6,-
%  J%6%" %,,8 @)4,6!68 4%!6 ,))(%,*6 
)%/,%%+,, , &,%%+,,. #% 4%)6!), %)%! 4%,,$)%+% -
,'.  +()% %&'%, 6%% ',  &' @64,,$),
4%((!3 %," % %,%6 ("),,  % # , ,)#))
',6%("),* Kjoue~ille8 9�:;8 9:H08 9:H;L8 %%! 4%6%+A )%3,
(6%,$)," )%"  .
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
% (6%),#A ,))(%,*  %&), )%/,!3 (,668 
@% 6, %'6%%+%8   %
&3%(,6%+%. !  )%B6 ,$+% )B-
%+% ,  %)%&%(6 )&* % 6%%" %)%),8 %+( 4,(#-
6!6 , )%3*6 ),6#!8 4%6%+A5, 6 4%#$ ',6%!+%(!
'#!. % ))* ) #%)A !(,+6!3 #$!6, 4(4%%-
," % %68 $% +#44! )+( %',#8 ), 6%% 4%#$, !+%(# (*
)38 % 6! ,3  4,,66. ) %*%) %+%8 $% 6%+, +#44! 
)6%+# (%&,)* %&5" !+%(! % )%6)!3 (")," ,'-' %)#),*
# ,3 #$),% ,, (%,* (#+  (#+#8 ,, %'6%%), (* +%+%
%&5,*8 ,, ,),#/,%!3 ,%/,"8 .. ),  )%'(! +#,-
#A5, , )/,%,#A5, 4, K.Ustrom8 9::7L. !  6%6 
&! #!6,  %68 $% )#5)# %% %(, ,4 %+,'/,, (*
B,* )3 )%/,!3 4%&6 %#!" !%8 4%)()%6
%%%+% A(,8 4)(#* )%, )%&)! ,)!8 4,3%(*  )%'(-
,A ',6%!+%(!3 &+. %)%# %! #)%,* )4%)%&)#A
%,!6 ("),*68 )(%%8 %)%%" '($" &#( )%'(-
, %!3 4,8 6%,/,* #$),%  ,3 !4%,8    !-
&%# 6 ',* (* 38 % $). %% )6, A(,8 %%)*)
 4,6   %6# 63,'6#8 6%+# #4* , #4* )%,
',6%%%B,*8 , ,* 4%,/,* ,, )#(  @%6 (  4%6%+#. 
, A(,  '3%, &! ,  %6 %&5)8 +( )%&A(, )3 4,
4%,)3%(, %% ) 4%6%5A 4%,/,,.
 4(+A 4%(%, '&%# %,, /,%%+% !&% %-
%+% 4%%,*. , @%6 %,,8 %)%!  4%%"8 % *%" /,%-
%),8 &#(# 5 ,+ #A %  B6 4%,6,, 4%(,*
$%8  $,8 %$! 4()',*8 ,)3%(*5, ,' %,, 4%%+% -
/,%%+% !&%8 &#(# )#, )%+% %( ,,$)%" &'%" % 6*
4%(,* @64,,$),3 ,))(%," ,, (* %/, 4,%),-
4,%), %&S*)," ,))(#6%+% 4%(,*8 4(+6!3 (#+,6,
%,*6,. )%%" %4%) ,))(%,* &#( %=  $6 ',$, 6(#
4()'!6 %),6 )%+)% %,, 4%%" /,%%), , -
&A(6!6 4%(,6T 1% %+%8 %,, ,+ # $, ,) )4%-
)%&!8  A$, 4#/,A8 ',6%) , ',$! %6! 4%(,* 
%,$), ,+%! 6%(, Kwbbink et al.8 9::DQ Yuth8 9::;Q qreps8 9::0Q
Valfray ` }osenthal8 9:FFQ }abin8 9::HQ Welten8 9::08 9::9L. %'6%%8 $% @,
6%(, /,%%+% 4%(,*8 %&#)%%+% 4,6,8 )# ,)-
4%'% &% ,%  )(#A56 ()*,,,.
%,* 4%%+% /,%%+% !&% 6% 4()* ,) (*
4%,,%  6%(, ,' 4%(%), ,),#% %'("),A
%!3 %)%$!3 )+,"8 )%'(6!3 ,!6,8 #6!6,8 @-
+,$!6, ,,6,. A&%" )'!" ,),#/,%!" ,' (%-
 A$ 4%6,6% ,))(%,* )4%)%&% %+,'/,, '%%(!3
4%/))%8 J%6# )$ ), , %'6%%)" (,(% , %,/," 4%&-
(,  !&%3 %'6%%), 'A$ (%+%% 4% 4%&66 %#A-
5" )(!8  , ,))(%, 4%(%), ,),#% 6,4#*/,-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
*6 )$,!38 $)!3 4%
. '( ) A(,8 %%! !#$,,
, 'A 4, ',6%), , ,# 4% ,68 % 6%+% , 38 % )6,)*
4%# 4%/)) ,6 %&'%68 $%&! 4%#$, &%B#A !+%(# (* )&*8
4%%)A ,+%,#* ,)! (#+,3. %@%6# )+( 4, "6  &%#
,3 A(" #% #$,!8 %! &#(# 4%)(),*.
6%" #%" 4%&6%"  )+%(*B," ( **)* %4(-
, )4, ,*,* )##!3 46!3  )%'(, #)4B!3 6%-
(" %,%+% ("),*. * %+% ,))(%,* 6%(, 4%(,*
$% %%+% 4%%,* 4%)% %
&3%(,6!. '* ), ) )#-
#! 46!  %(# &%B#A %,A 4,$,!3 )*'"  ),# ,3
6%+%$,)%), , &%B%" ',),6%), % /%), (#+,3 46!3.
% %'6%% )(8  @% '&% %+,$), 4%)(%! #-
6#*,! %,$), )/,,8 %%! $,A)* ) %%),%
4%)!3 &'%!3 6%(" , 43%(*  %J,/,!6 6%(*6 4%!3 ,)-
)(%,". %',B* 4, @%6 %,*  (  +%&!6 (#6!6
,, 6%+%6!6 4()',*68 $+% %$ &! 3%, 6%+, #$!.
@ , , K9�::L )%'(, /!" *( ,3 %,$),3 )/,
B,* )%/,!3 (,66 (* &%B%" +#44! +%+!3 #$),%
%,%+% ("),*. , 4,B,  (,%6# !%(# %%),% 3-
 %,$)%+% , @64,,$)%+% 4(4,*,*= !  #(68
$% %'6%% )( %&5, %,$), 4()',*8 ,)4%'#* B
4%(3%(8 6! )$,68 $% %,  6%+# &! 4%)!6, , +%&!6,. -
%&%%8 B, 4()',*8 %%! 6! (6 %&%)%%8 (%! &!
)%!6,8 #)%!6, , ,,!6, K). 2;L.
 4%,%%+, 6! (%! 4,' % J8 $% 4%,,$), ),)-
6! %+,'%! %$ )%%8 , 6!  )+( 6%6 #(8 $% %(
46* )*' ) (#+%"8 ',),6%" %  46%"8 4%%,%
,, %,/%. # # ),* ),),8 #% ' /-
%) (#+,3 46!38   4%)% (%4#)8 $% %, %,$A)*  )(-
6  4(3 ,3-% ,$,.
'&% 6%(" 4(% /,%%+% , 6%%+% 4%(,*
%%+% 4%%,* ), 6%+% %!3 %4%)% 4( )%/,%%+,"8 &,%%-
+," , *(%6 (#+,3 #8 )*'!3 ) ,'#$,6 $%. % %4%)!= 
A(, (%&,A)* (%,*T  @% (%, 6*)* 4%( %'("),6 '-
!3 ,),#/,%!3 4)%T , $! ,, ,'#! A$,
4,6*A)* (* %/, 4%(,* (#+,3T  %(! ,/ 4,3%(* 
&3%(,6%), )%'( 4, , )(% ,6T %
& ), *( ,)!3 %4%)%= 4%$6# A(, %&S(,*A)*  -
$ @)4,6T  6!  @,3 ,+3 !&,6 )& 4T  B
)+,* !&% 4% %,$)* % )+,, A$,* ,3  +#44#
,, ,)A$,* ,' T
,&% )#5)! %4%)! )A)* %+%8  #)%%$! 4-
, )4%)%&)#A )%'(,A ,, %+,$,A ',6%+% (%,*8 ',6-
%), , 4#/,,. %)(, ,))(%,* 4%&6! %+%%+% )%+-
)%,* K
L )* *( !3 %4%)% %%),% @,),,
(%,*8 ,)4%'#6%" A(6,8 , ,3 /,,  4%4!, 4,)
#4* 4%/))%6 )%+)%,*. ,B%6 &%B% 6B)% 6%
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
!' %&#A /,A= A(, ,#,,% 4%$#)#A8 $% ,6  (%-
*A ,8 ,6 %&'%68 )6, )# 6 (!6,8 6 (%)%"!6,
(%,* K{rey8 9�::L. 1#% M" K9::7L 4!)* !*),8 #6BA ,
J%6! ,),#/,%! #)%,8 ,  )%/,% )3%-
, , %4 4% $)# %%+% #(8 %*%) %+%8 $% A(,
4%-46# &#(# (! 4%%,!" )6!)  ("),*8 )%B-
6!  %)%%6 4% #)%!6 #,6 %66. ( A(, 6%+#
)$,8 $% ' %J,/,%" %+,'/,, 4(%)% 4% '&%,)*
% )%6)!3 #(38 '$, ',6%) K)%6)! ("),*L &%B 
#! K)6.= jaylor8 9:F7L.
) 4, #'%,A 4,6,  )%%)#A5,3 )/,"
 6 ,/68 % @, 4,  !4%*8  , +(, (%)%"!3.
% ) ,' +#44! ,)A$A)* 8 %  ,6A ,%" 6%,/,, )%#(,-
$8 %6  ,'& )/,". ,3 )#$*3 ) %,(A 4,6,*
6%(" 4%+% 4%%,*. %(, %%+% 4%%,* &#(# 4,6*)*
) 68 $%&! #'8  %),#/,%! 4, , 4, %,%+%
!&% ,*A  )4(, (
%3%(% ,  %'6%%) ',6%!+%(-
%+% )%#(,$). % ,))(%,*8  4,%8 4%%(,,) 4% #)4B-
!68 (%+%)%$!68 )6%)%*% %',B,6 ,),#68 4%@%6# %$
6% 6,% ,))(%," ,),#%8  4,6*B,3)* %) ,,
4%) )%,3  #)43 4,B(B,3  +%(%). 1%B, #),,* 4%-
&#A)*8 $%&! ,'$ ,' (!3 3,% , 4, , !*),8
4%$6# %, 4), &%.
%'6%%8 4%)* )!6 %8 $% *  4%+A)  @)4,-
6% ,))(%,. * @%+% ) )%% 4,$,. % 6 %+%
 %,* )%,)*8  ,%+( B8 %)%%" B+% 4(6 4%-
,%%+,,8 @)4,6 A$)*   #$#A 6%(,# @64,,$)%+%
,))(%,*.  ',6A) #$!6 ,))(%,6 % #� ;  , 4%@%-
6# 'A8  %8 % ,  #(% 4%, %,A  4%!3 #)%,*38
%)%&% %+( 46! (")#A ,,%. )B&! 4%!
,)4!,* &#(# 4%-46# +!6 ,)%$,%6 @64,,$),3 (!38
% @, @)4,6! $)% &!A ),B%6 (%%+,6 , @JJ,!6
6%(%6 (* ,' 4%&6! ,*,* ,),#/,%!3 ),6#%8 
',),6%), % ,3 %6&,/,"8  4%(, (%+% ,(,,(##6 , 
'#! ,3 )%6)!3 ("),". ! &!, &! &% 4%)(%!
 )%,3 ,))(%,*3 , 4%(,+,) &!)8 ), &! 6! 4%*, +,-
4%'# % 4%,%&%)#A5,3 @63  ',$!3 6%(*3 , %,*3 
4(3 )%+)%%" )36!. 5% '&%! @)4,6-
! 4%! $)% 4%6%+A !(, +,4%'! %#% &!)8 $6
4%4!, %4(, %$#A %6&,/,A 46!3  4%!3 ,))(%-
,*3. %&**  4%!6 ,))(%,*6 @)4,6#A 6%(,#8
4%,,$)* # OO . )% 4%#$, 3%%B% %&%)%#A %,A
% 4%(,, $% , % ,*,,  +% '!3 ,),#/,%!3 (%-
+%%%)".
%&! &%%! ,))(%,* %$, ,,*6 %"
("),%),8 ,3 #% 4%(4* (!6, 4%!6, ,))(%-
,*6,.
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
,%% 4,6, %,, /,%%), (  ,%6# 4%,6-
,A %, +%)#(). ), ))6, A("  ,!38 &)4%-
6%5!3 +(8 % +%)#()% &#( !)#4  B** )8 -
BA5* 4%&6! ' )3 , (%+%. ), 4,* %8 $% A(,8 %4,*)
 @,),# , %6!8 6%+# /!" *( 4%&6 B )6%)%*%8
 (* B,* (#+,3 )%'( %! )##! 6%(,8 % , 4%,6-
, %+%8 ,6 (%% &! +%)#()% , $% %% (%% (8 )-
 ,!6. ,)6 #4"B,3 +%)#() 4,3%(,)* !4%*
6%+% J#/,"= %&)4$, +%)#()%" &'%4)%),Q %)#5)-
, J,)%%" , B" 4%,,,8 B" %+%%" 4%,,,Q 4%-
(,8 4% %'6%%),8 #6%" 4%,,, 4)4(,*Q 4%(-
(, 6, , )4%%"),*  )8 %+( %',A +#44! A("8
)6*5,3)* 4%,,)* ' )$ (#+,3Q 4%(, (%)%%" ,J%-
6/,%%" 4%,,,Q B, 4%&6 /,%%+% 3 , .(.
% /,%! +%)#() ),B%6 6!8 $%&! #4* %(%6 
+%&%6 6)B&8 , ),B%6 ,,8 $%&! ',6)* 4%&66,
&%B%+% 6)B&.
%'( )%#A 6%+%#%#A ),)6# +%)#()%+% #4-
,* %$ #(%. ?() %', 6%+% %4%)%8 4,6= 4%((,-
A ,, %+A %6! ',6%),  ,, ,! %&S(,,*  #%
,3,, ), ,  +#4438 +( BA)* 4%&6! %,%+% #$-
),* K{rohlich ` Uppenheimer8 9:70Q Yal|art8 9::2LT %! ,))(%,*
4%',8 $% % )3 4%$!3 %&S(,,*38 ,6A5,3 %&5," 4,8
4%',,! , +,! )/,,  )()% %%* 4,&,A)* 
#,)!6 KX.Ustrom8 9::0L8 a @% +%%, % %68 $% &' B" 4%(-
(, ,3 %+,'/," ',6%) )6 4% )& *( , B, &%
)%! 4%&6!. &, ,6,8 $% )/,, #)%$A)* 4%)-
4%8   #),A)* ),6, ) )6%+% $. %+, 4%&6!8
)*'! )% ',6%)A8 %'6%% %&S*), ) 4%6%5A )#5)#-
A5" %,, 4)#4,*8 %%* %)%  )%+%" %,, %,(-
6!3 %/%. ), A(, 6%+# #$,)* ',6%),  %)%%" %6
%+,'/,, ,3 ,',8 ), %, )%+BA)*  ,-% (%4%,!
4,8 %&#)%! 4(!(#5,6,8 % 4%+)),! )/,, (A
$% &%B8 $6 %% )(,, )%B,* #B,".
 %6 K4,L ',6%), ) , 6! )%%!. %)%# )*-
%+% %( #B,* 4,%(*  #)%$,A 6 ',*8 % +#44!8
%%!6 #(%) B, )%/,! 4%&6!8 )6 %*% )#
6%$,)!6,8 )%)%*5,6,  %)%%6 ,' %(),% , (#'"8 %-
%! &#(# %%4,%)* (#+ ) (#+%68 (&% %%)*) % )6
B,6 46 K}.Zardin8 9::;L. * 6%( %%B," 6%
4,),  )4*6 , ( %!6 ("),*6 K^oyd ` }icherson8 9::2Q
Chagnon8 9:FFQ Xlster8 9:F;Q qollock8 9�::L8  +%%* # % )%%"8 -
,+,%'%" , @,$)%" (,),6,/,,. %)4%()#A5*  %%B,*3
,(* #)#+ ' #)#+# @% %)% %#4/,,. %6#-% %$ !+%(%8
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
$%&! %%! )%/,! 4%&6! %)  B,)8 4,6
)*'! ) %&'%,6 6%%4%," , "8 %%!  4,'A
6% , '%8 44*)#A )%'(,A %!%+% %&5) , ',,A
@%%6,,. %,,8 4(+A5* !3%( ,' &+%4%#$%" ),#-
/,,8  %
&3%(,68  , 4%,,8 )%'(A5* &+%4,*! #)%-
,* (* %6%" (*%),.
)%,* $%$) 4%'! 68 $% %,$)% 4,-
)% $)% ( %"#  %% ) B,6 +%68 % , ) )%&)-
!6 %(%6. (6%,$),3 +%)#()3 'B, %J,!3
),#/,"8  )(, %(!3 A("8  , 6(# +#446,8 4%,)3%(,
&' 4,6,* %%#!3 ),8 &' 6))%!3 #&,"). 6%,* (%-
%% 3#4," ,),# ),8   )+( 4%**)* %'6%%)
6,4#,% A8 ), +( , 4(),, ), (%)%$%
&(,!. %@%6#8 ), 6! 3%,6  OO . ,  6,8 #%8 $%&! )(-
! 6, %!,*  '# ,))(%," %,!3 ("),"
), %&*'!6, (* ,'#$,*  )B,3 ))3 B% ,  !)B,3
#$&!3 '(,*3. ) B, #$&,, +%%* %% % 4%,,$),3 (-
**38  $% 5 3#8 %% % /,%!3 4%,,$),3 (**3. #-
(!8 'B* %&5," #) 4% 6,)%6# +%)#()%6# )%A
,, 4%,%%+,,8  4%(%'A % %68 $% %, )6, ,+A )#5)-
#A %  )%3,, (6%,,. #$&,3 +%%,)* % %68 $% #$-
), +(  4%,,$)%" ,', )! )%)%,  4%((,, )*',
) ,'&!6, ,(6,8  %+,'/,, +#44 ,)%8 4,"8 4%(-
,, !&%%8  %8 $% +(6 #! #6,* , !, B )%*5,
4( ,6, )%/,! (,66!8 %)*)* &' ,6,*.  %&)#(-
)* , 4%&6 6%%+% !&%8 6%* )%% 4,*,* B-
,". %@%6# 6! %)4,!6 4%%, /,,%8  ,)4!!A5,3 %)%-
&%+% (%,* (#+  (#+#8 , # 6 &%  )%6# 4,)#. ),
4, B,, )%/,!3 4%&6 %)%!6 &%,6  #$),6
&#( 4%*, (%,*8 % 6! )6 )%'( , #)%,*8 %%!
,'6* ) B (6%,$)," %&' ,',. ( @% 4%)! A(,8
+( )%'(A , 4%((,A &%# %+,'/," , ,),#% -
),. ! %&*'! 4( &#(#5,6 4%%,*6 ',* % %68  $%#
'%&)*  %(%'$%), )%/,!3 (,668  ,3 B8 %+(
%, 4( ,6 )#.
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
9. wbbink q.8 ^olton Y.X.8 Wadrieh w.8 jang {.{. 9::D. wdapti~e \earning ~ersus
2. wbreau . 9:FF. Un the jheory of nfinitely }epeated Yames ith iscounting.
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
�:. Coleman .W. 9:F7. orms as Wocial Capital. n Xconomic mperialism= jhe Xconomic
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
:7. Zarsahyi .C.8 Welten }. 9:FF. w Yeneral jheory of Xuilibrium Welection in Yames.
:F. Zirshleifer .8 }asmusen X. 9:F:. Cooperation in a }epeated Vrisoners ilemma ith
::. Zoffman X.8 _cCabe q.8 Wmith . 9::Da. ^eha~ioral {oundations of }eciprocity=
of Xconomics8 ni~ersity of wrizona8 jucson.900. Zoffman X.8 _cCabe q.8 Wmith . 9::Db. Wocial istance and Uther-}egarding
909. �Zollingshead w.^.8 _cYrath .X.8 UConnor q._. 9::. Yroup jask Verformance and
���902. Zolmstrom ^. 9:F2. _oral Zazard in jeams. ^ell ournal of Xconomics.
�90. Zomans Y.C. 9:D9. Wocial ^eha~ior= ts Xlementary {orms. e ]ork= Zarcourt8
90H. saac }._.8 _cCue q.8 Vlott C.}. 9:F;. Vublic Yoods Vro~ision in an Xxperimental
tary Contribution _echanism. Xconomic nuiry. 2DKUctoberL=;F;-D0F.90D. saac }._.8 [alker . 9:FFb. Yroup Wize Xffects in Vublic Yoods Vro~ision= jhe oluntary
907. saac }._.8 [alker . 9::9. Costly Communication= wn Xxperiment in ested Vublic
90F. �saac }._.8 [alker . 9::. ash as an Urganizing Vrinciple in the oluntary Vro-
^loomington.90:. saac }._.8 [alker .8 jhomas W. 9:FH. i~ergent X~idence on {ree }iding= wn Xx-
990. saac }._.8 [alker .8 [illiams w.[. 9::H. Yroup Wize and the oluntary Vro~ision
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
99;. qnight . 9::2. nstitutions and Wocial Conflict. Cambridge= Cambridge ni~ersity
99D. �qollock V. 9::. wn Xye for an Xye \ea~es X~eryone ^lind= Cooperation and wccounting
997. qreps . _. 9::0. Corporate Culture and Xconomic jheory. n Verspecti~es on Vositi~e
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
��9. _cCay ^..8 wcheson ._. 9:F7. jhe uestion of the Commons= jhe Culture and
�9H. _cqean _. 9::2. Wuccess on the CommonQ w Comparati~e Xxamination of Common
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
9;9. Urbell ._.8 aes }._.8 ~an de qragt w. 9::0.jhe \imits of _ultilateral Vromising.
9;2. Urbell ._.8 Wchartz-Whea V.8 Wimmons }. 9:FH. o Cooperator Xxit _ore than
�9;. Urbell ._.8 ~an de qragt w.8 aes }._. 9:FF. Xxplaining iscussion-nduced
9;H. Ustrom X. 9::0. Yo~erning the Commons= jhe X~olution of nstitutions for Collecti~e
9;;. Ustrom X. .d. Welf-Yo~ernance of Common-Vool }esources. n jhe e Valgra~e
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
9FF. Wchlager X. 9::0. _odel Wpecification and Volicy wnalysis= jhe Yo~ernance of Coastal
9F:. �Wchlager X.8 Ustrom X. 9::. Vroperty-}ights }egimes and Coastal {isheries= wn
9:0. Wchneider {.8 Vommerehne [.[. 9:F9. {ree }iding and Collecti~e wction=
9:9. Wcholz .j.. jrust8 jaxes and Compliance. n jrust and Yo~ernance8 ed. alerie
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
20D. Wmith . 9:F2. _icroeconomic Wystems as an Xxperimental Wcience. wmerican
207. Wnidal . 9:F;. Coordination ~ersus Vrisoners ilemma= mplications for
20F. jang W.]. 9::2. nstitutions and Collecti~e wction= Collecti~e wction= Welf-Yo~ernance
20:. jaylor _. 9:F7. jhe Vossibility of Cooperation. e ]ork= Cambridge ni~ersity
290. jhibaut .[.8 qelley Z.Z. 9:;:. jhe Wocial Vsychology of Yroups. e ]ork= [iley.
299. �jocue~ille w. de. K9F; and 9FH0L9:H;. emocracy in wmerica. 2 ~ols. Xd. Vhillips
292. jri~ers }. \. 9:79. jhe X~olution of }eciprocal wltruism. uarterly }e~ie of ^iology.
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
�22. ]amagishi j.8 Zayashi . 9::D. Welecti~e Vlay= Wocial Xmbeddedness of Wocial
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
(()))/,, ) (,66%" %#+ %&5)!3 )#)% &!% '6$%8 $%  ,3 %)% ,   (,66 #$)% ,,  #$)%8 $% ,  @)4,63 ) )%'(,6 %&5)!3 &+8 4,$6 4%(, A("  @)4,63 ) %&5)!6, )#)6, &' %'6%%), %&5,* '$,% %,$)* % 4%(,* A("  @)4,63 4% )%'(,A %&5)!3 &+ % &' %'6%%), %&5,*. , 4%%,, @)4,6 ) %&5)!6, )#-)6, '# 4,&,)*  #)%"$,%" ),#/,, ) Nash equilibrium ,'#8 
%)6, @)4,63 ) '!6 ,6%6 , %&5,6 %,$),6 4%+%-
$),, ,+ Centipede %  ,)4%'#A 6%( %&%" ,(#/,,
'* %&S*), #A 4#)/,A8 ,)4%'#* 4%#A 6%( /,%%),8
90 %,, %%4,%" ,+!8 %&%%8 4(4%+)*8 $% ,+%, %&5A)*
% 6* @)4,6 #$),, %,6% 4,,6A B,*8 , %4
9:7H +. 5 #6 '6,8 $% ,+%, ),A)* ) 4%&6%" %&3%(,-
6. )(#A5,3 %%8 4,B#5,3 % 4%',,%6 @JJ )4%)%&%), %&5-
. �. *  6* 8   :B =&#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000; =*   &#x. 8;�;&#x* ;&#x-10 ;* ;&#x 8 ;&#x :; -10;&#x-1;� =;1;� ;&#x=000;*...
1% %+%8 %, (!A  J%( &%B8 ), BJ &! &% ,',6 ,,
%'(* J%6! 6%(,8 6%% %(, 4%',
K(L %$-
K(L
'6,*  %/3 4%(,* , )*'%+% ) ,6 '# 6%+# 4%,)-
#( K9:D98 979L )$,8 $% %6 ',6%), #,) ,   -
6.= % K9:FDL. +% (,)#)),* 4% 4%%(# )%&)%" , % O),,
%( , )%6 K9::;L ))6,A @, 4%&6! &% +#&%%. 6. 
%& )%( %' ),% ,*,  @%A/,%!" 4%(3%(  %,,
E)* ),)6 ',*
% 4%!" )4,)% )3 ,(% %6 ',6%),. ?() 4(+A)* ,B
A("8 4,(,A5,3)* B)%" %6!8 %$ 6%8 6%% )'8 ,3 )%-
%4%)! +%)#()%+% , 6#,/,4%+% #4,*. 2090. P 9
O%J68 .%#& , 6, K9::DL 4%%(,, @)4,6!  (,%),3
�M8 ,%,$ , "+ K9::L B,8 $% )4%)%&%) #$),% @)4,-
),#/,, 4%%" %4(%),8 %+( #$)#A %% ( $%8
6%% +% 4,6* '6,#A )+,A #)#+ ' #)#+# ( &'
4(,%+% %&5,*. ), &%B* $) ),* 4,(,)*
%" )+,,8 ), %, 6%+# #%$,8 ) 6 %, ',6%(")%, 
, 6! ',* ' #B, (%+%% % )%#(,$)L8 ), #$!
6, Kwxelrod8 9:FH8 9:FDL.
@)4,6% #$),,  #B, )%+B,*
(%%8 (* &#(#5,3 ,))(%," 4%&6 %'("),* ,),#/,%-
!3 #)%%  )+,, , '#! &#( %))* #%".
�6.= wgraal n.d.Q wlt and Whepsle8 9::0Q ^ates8 9:F:Q asgupta8 9::Q Xggertsson8
�9::0Q Yibson n.d.Q \e~i8 9::7Q . Ustrom8 9::7Q . Ustrom8 {eeny8 and Vicht8 9::Q

Приложенные файлы

  • pdf 18395515
    Размер файла: 228 kB Загрузок: 0

Добавить комментарий